4 ms·
Austria to introduce new carbon tax next year
- mlinksva 5y agoGood for Austria. From the article it seems they figured out a way to pay off rural voters (larger carbon dividend in areas with poor transit) and energy intensive industries (other tax cuts). I'd rather not see such provisions, but they're very pragmatic, and minor relative to the achievement. Copy round the world.
- option 5y agoI wish G7,G20 or the whole UN adapt carbon tax. I am afraid that it is something doomed to fail if adapted by individual nations (especially by those who aren’t polluting much by themselves). If adapted by the whole world it would be such a wonderful thing both for environment and economies because it would incentivize development and adoption of new clean tech. Because otherwise people would simply “outsource” the pollution which is, of course, a ridiculous concept.
- mlinksva 5y agoSuch coordination would be great, but carbon taxes aren't doomed to fail without it. I'd guess that every country has taxes that are worse for competitiveness than a carbon tax, and can be displaced. Additionally, carbon border adjustments can partially impose a carbon tax on producers in countries that won't do it themselves.
- option 5y agoAgree, unfortunate such coordination is not going to happen. Carbon border adjustments is a great idea which could make carbon taxes work.
- extropy 5y agoIMO not practical and not needed, just add an import duty from countries without carbon tax to price in the externalities. And the market will figure it out. The duty can be a flat rate or an average emissions per economic output for the country.
- moralestapia 5y agoI'm all in regarding this but I see a big issue regarding corruption and nepotism. For instance, it does not say that in TFA, but it is implied that some sort of fund would have to be created to manage and distribute all that new money. Let's consider that, as a natural consequence, a big part of that money goes to buying carbon credits/offsets; that's a billion euro bill that is going to make "the right person" very rich, very fast. And before one says something like "but we are not like that", just remember Austria just came out of a huge political crisis a few years ago. Imagine what would happen to this money in other least developed countries. A possible solution would be to keep things as democratic and transparent as they could possibly be.
- truthwhisperer 5y agoBasically a free money transfer from developed countries to corrupt shithole countries? Big no no
- xqcgrek2 5y agoTithes must be paid. Those who sin more must pay more in their confessionals.
- throw0101a 5y agoFunds collected will be refunded and not kept by the government: > Each resident in Austria will get an annual reimbursement, with the exact amount determined by where they live to ensure those in rural regions without good public transport don’t lose out. Children are entitled to half their parents’ amount — so a family of two adults and two children in Vienna could expect to get 300 euros ($358) for example. While the term "tax" is used proverbially, if the government does not keep the money, it is actually a tax? This was a constitutional question in Canada, and the majority of the Supreme Court ruled that it was not: > As a final matter, the fuel and excess emission charges imposed by the GGPPA have a sufficient nexus with the regulatory scheme to be considered constitutionally valid regulatory charges. To be a regulatory charge, as opposed to a tax, a governmental levy with the characteristics of a tax must be connected to a regulatory scheme. The first step is to identify the existence of a relevant regulatory scheme; if such a scheme is found to exist, the second step is to establish a relationship between the charge and the scheme itself. Influencing behaviour is a valid purpose for a regulatory charge and regulatory charges need not reflect the cost of the scheme. The amount of a regulatory charge whose purpose is to alter behaviour is set at a level designed to proscribe, prohibit, or lend preference to a behaviour. Limiting such a charge to the recovery of costs would be incompatible with the design of a scheme of this nature. Nor must the revenues that are collected be used to further the purposes of the regulatory scheme. Rather, the required nexus with the scheme will exist where the charges themselves have a regulatory purpose. There is ample evidence that the fuel and excess emission charges imposed by Parts 1 and 2 of the GGPPA have a regulatory purpose. They cannot be characterized as taxes; rather, they are regulatory charges whose purpose is to advance the GGPPA’s regulatory purpose by altering behaviour. […] > [219] In the instant case, there is ample evidence that the fuel and excess emission charges imposed by Parts 1 and 2 of the GGPPA have a regulatory purpose. Ontario does not assert, nor would such an assertion be supportable, that the levies in this case amount to disguised taxation. The GGPPA as a whole is directed to establishing minimum national standards of GHG price stringency to reduce GHG emissions, not to the generation of revenue. As Richards C.J.S. aptly observed, the GGPPA “could fully accomplish its objectives . . . without raising a cent”: para. 87. This is true of both Part 1 and Part 2. The levies imposed by Parts 1 and 2 of the GGPPA cannot be characterized as taxes; rather, they are regulatory charges whose purpose is to advance the GGPPA’s regulatory purpose by altering behaviour. The levies are constitutionally valid regulatory charges. * https://www.canlii.org/en/ca/scc/doc/2021/2021scc11/2021scc11.html https://www.canlii.org/en/ca/scc/doc/2021/2021scc11/2021scc1... * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenhouse_Gas_Pollution_Pricing_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenhouse_Gas_Pollution_Prici... Canada is a federation, and the national and provincial governments each have their areas of responsibility. There were challenges whether there was federal over reach, and the court said there was not given the structure of the legislation. * https://elc.ab.ca/i-read-the-carbon-tax-decision-so-you-dont-have-to-a-detailed-summary-of-the-main-issues/ https://elc.ab.ca/i-read-the-carbon-tax-decision-so-you-dont...
- olah_1 5y agoNaturally this means nothing for the ruling class and is devastating to the middle and lower classes. Why does every single policy lately lead to further consolidation…
- paganel 5y agoI feel we'll soon enough have a Brexit/Trump moment with these regressive taxes labeled as "environmental" taxes.
- AdrianB1 5y agoThey are trying to reduce carbon emissions, not to be progressive or regressive. It looks like a measure for improving climate, not income redistribution.
- bserge 5y agoYeah, if they manage it like Covid, people will riot. Everyone likes to talk about reducing their carbon footprint and shit, but push come to shove, no one wants to give up their lifestyle. Especially not the middle and upper classes. In the end, a bunch of people will just have to die, it's the only real solution.
- livueta 5y agoNot sure why this would be downed; it's a real issue, e.g. https://www.economist.com/britain/an-anti-green-backlash-could-reshape-british-politics/21804957 https://www.economist.com/britain/an-anti-green-backlash-cou... In a way, it really is a bit of a "no shit" observation: actually effective climate action is incompatible with democracy unless quality of life is broadly maintained or improved. And people shouldn't point at warm-and-fuzzy nonsense like polls claiming to show 80+% support for "saving the climate" and similarly vague statements. Imma just leave this here: https://ballotpedia.org/Washington_Initiative_1631,_Carbon_Emissions_Fee_Measure_(2018) https://ballotpedia.org/Washington_Initiative_1631,_Carbon_E... In fucking Washington. By those margins. Support for climate action disintegrates as soon as people see the personal downside, so we need to figure out how to develop and present lifestyle-positive climate interventions (like the revenue-neutrality of this Austrian thing!) if we want any serious motion in the West. I'm starting to look at the more self-flagellatory proposals as likely false flags from those opposed to serious change: as long as the burden of decarbonization falls on the little guy and his evil evil burgers, they can rest assured knowing that no serious action will ever pass anywhere important.
- BurningFrog 5y agoThere is a US campaign for this kind of carbon tax that gets paid back to the people: https://citizensclimatelobby.org/price-on-carbon/ https://citizensclimatelobby.org/price-on-carbon/ This is something even conservatives can get on board with.
- shkkmo 5y agoI suspect it will be seen as wealth redistribution by creating a new tax and thus would not be supported by most conservatives. I think to get conservatives on-board you would have to mandate that all income from such a tax is used to remove or reduce other taxes.
- throw0101a 5y ago> I suspect it will be seen as wealth redistribution by creating a new tax and thus would not be supported by most conservatives. Former Federeal Reserve Chairs Alan Greenspan, Ben Bernanke, Paul Volcker, and Janet Yellen (now at Treasury)—plus thousands of economists and dozens of Nobel laureates—signed support for carbon pricing: > V. To maximize the fairness and political viability of a rising carbon tax, all the revenue should be returned directly to U.S. citizens through equal lump-sum rebates. The majority of American families, including the most vulnerable, will benefit financially by receiving more in “carbon dividends” than they pay in increased energy prices. * https://clcouncil.org/economists-statement/ https://clcouncil.org/economists-statement/ Not that logic is used much nowadays in the GOP, but if Greenspan of all people can sign onto it…
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bserge 5y agoIntroduce tax for citizens but reduce taxes for companies that would be affected by it? Does that sound idiotic only to me? You reduce taxes for these companies... so they can afford to keep polluting the same as before, and place the burden on the end consumer? Uhh, what?
- slownews45 5y agoFantastic move by Austria, finally someone get's it, and is going to do it in a fair way instead of crap gimmicks!
- bserge 5y agoSometimes I think Russia has it right. No one can push them into stupid decisions, like the EU does with neighbouring countries. That's for Europe, of course. The US is king of pollution per capita and they don't give a flying fuck.
- slownews45 5y agoActually, a lot of US enviro spending is wildly market distorting and of dubious benefit. Ethanol from corn. Tons on the "hydrogen superhighways". etc
- vages 5y agoAny well run company will reduce its emissions if it’s cost effective, independent of whether the cost of pollution has been neutralised by a tax break.
- systemvoltage 5y agoSeems like it is serving the loud voter base - climate activists, meanwhile the real impact of climate change through power generation, agriculture, construction industry, aviation, etc. is being swept under the rug. In California, the last nuclear powerplant was shutdown this week. I am going to do what I can as a responsible citizen for climate change but I am not a fan of this asymmetry.
- nemo44x 5y agoThat will add about $300 to an overseas first/business class ticket. About $90 for economy.