2 ms·
But why do the Romani get an entire subclass, when Africa – ALL of Africa, is also just one subclass?
by cratermoon 5y ago
But why do the Romani get an entire subclass, when Africa – ALL of Africa, is also just one subclass?
- dredmorbius 5y agoPut simply: - The classification, as all classifications do, is both current and historical, and reflects the biases of the periods over which it evolved. - The classification serves a pragmatic purpose, as all subject-based shelving classifications do, of reflecting the need to assign volumes of a large collection of books to a single shelf location for both access and reshelving. - Most classification systems also attempt to bucket all of human knowledge into a fixed number of buckets (20 in the case of the LoCCS), which results in compromises and awkwardness. Additional knowledge and changes in surrounding human culture tend to make earlier structures awkward, if not fully obsolete. - In the late 19th / early 20th century, not only was there little extant literature on African history, but there was comparatively little interest at the US Library of Congress, as well as considerable cultural antipathy in the United States generally given the country's racist history and politics at the time. (The areas of interest can be surmised by viewing the history classification: the United States itself, North and South America, Europe, with a particular focus on England and Western Europe, and generally The Rest of the World.) All topical classifications and ontologies are artefacts of their times. The history of catalogists, encyclopaedists, science, history, and philosophy makes this clear. There are ideas which come and go, some rapidly, some establish themselves solidly for centuries or millennia. This is one of the occupational hazards of the practice. What the US Library of Congress Classification System does have, as I've tried to express above, is both an ability to expand within the classification system (dive into the Africa section and it expands in subclasses), and a process for accommodating change. Subclassifications can be retired, and terminology changed. It's a process, not a product.
- cratermoon 5y agoThat doesn't explain why the Romani needed an entire subclass. What was the bias there, when it was "History of Gypsies"? Was there really that much published about them at the time? As much about them alone as all of Asia, or all of Africa, or even about all of Central Europe?
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'd suggest re-reading my previous comment. On the context of the D Class: Class D, History, was first drafted in 1901 and after undergoing revision was published in 1916. Two supplements were published: European War (first edition, 1921; second edition, 1933; reprinted in 1954 with additions and changes), and Second World War (1947). The second edition of class D was published in 1959, containing additions and changes through June 1957. A reprint edition was published in 1966, containing a supplementary section of additions and changes through July 1965. The third edition was published in five parts between 1987 and 1990: D-DJ, DJK-DK, DL-DR, DS, and DT-DX. Subclasses DS-DX, History of Asia, Africa, Australia, New Zealand, etc., were published in a single edition in 1998, complemented by a 2001 edition of D-DR. A subsequent edition was published in 2008, followed by an edition in 2012. Annual editions have appeared beginning in 2015. This 2021 edition of DS-DX cumulates all additions and changes that have been made since the publication of the 2020 edition. https://www.loc.gov/aba/publications/FreeLCC/LCC_DS-DX2021PRF.pdf https://www.loc.gov/aba/publications/FreeLCC/LCC_DS-DX2021PR... For the divisions within the subclass, see: pp. 334--335: https://www.loc.gov/aba/publications/FreeLCC/LCC_DS-DX2021TEXT.pdf https://www.loc.gov/aba/publications/FreeLCC/LCC_DS-DX2021TE... Culturally, the Romani are distinct within Europe, in having their own language and practices, and are a nomadic / diaspora group without a specific homeland and a long history of presence, and often various frictional interactions with, numerous other cultures, nations, and states. Given that the group is tacked on at the end of the global history section, it doesn't seem to have an exceptionally high significance within the classification. Other than that, I don't know what the rationale is, and I've tried to convey that I don't. Do you have a specific argument against establishing a category for this culture?