3 ms·
> "In two decades the SEC hasn’t brought a single insider trading case involving trades made under a 10b5-1 plan." Ladies and gentlemen of the jury: the defend
by AlbertCory 5y ago
> "In two decades the SEC hasn’t brought a single insider trading case involving trades made under a 10b5-1 plan."
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury: the defendant changed his 10b5-1 plan multiple times, and one of those times he profited hugely from it. The defendant's excuse that his advisor told him to do it and he needed the money for his daughter's college is just unpersuasive.
Anyone see why a prosecutor might be reluctant to bring such a case? It might well be true, but the jury may or may not stay awake long enough to agree. Best to concentrate scarce resources on cases you CAN win.
Note that I'm not saying insider trading is harmless; just that it's like illegal drugs: no policies will stamp it out entirely.
- smolder 5y ago"No policies we have tried or are collectively willing to try will stamp it out" is the accurate version of your ending statement, whether talking about drugs or insider trading. It's unreasonable to rule out every policy as only an infinitesimal portion have been explored. How best to organize humanity might be the least solvable and most open ended problem conceivable, one worthy of a multiverse scale simulation. We can't make solid predictions about what inputs lead to what outcomes. Species-wide conclusions about the impossibility of ending some specific immoral behavior depend on an expectation of irrationality from people, that they're unable to abandon the status quo.
- satellites 5y agoAdditionally, what is “immoral” is relative. I think an individual choosing to consume illegal drugs is perfectly moral, but lots of people disagree about that.