3 ms·
And with the frequency with which police find unregistered guns locally making traffic stops, I fully support this. It baffles me the repeated efforts locally
by colechristensen 5y ago
And with the frequency with which police find unregistered guns locally making traffic stops, I fully support this. It baffles me the repeated efforts locally to "reform" policing involve stopping these kinds of police activities to seem more fair or something... Don't get me wrong there are some really shady tactics in this realm police do use and having the job biases you towards certain assumptions, but still. Criminals are stupid, please keep giving them the opportunity to give themselves up by speeding in unregistered cars, etc.
- danenania 5y agoIt's not worth it when you have both innocent people and cops themselves frequently getting killed as a result. There are plenty of other ways to catch stupid criminals that don't carry the same risks. These practices also create a generally high level of fear and animosity toward police which isn't good for anyone.
- colechristensen 5y agoIf it's a numbers game, what are the numbers that make it worth it or not? "worth it" judgements shouldn't be made about what numbers justify other numbers if you aren't ready to have a priori numbers ready (as opposed to saying "this isn't justified because statistics" after the fact).
- danenania 5y agoIt’s not a numbers game at all. On one side you have actual innocent people (and cops) who are killed, assaulted, traumatized. On the other side, in the best case scenario, you are maybe preventing a hypothetical crime that maybe causes someone harm—and even that could have potentially been prevented through other means without the bad externalities. It’s a stupid trade.
- colechristensen 5y ago>It's not worth it when you have both innocent people and cops themselves frequently getting killed as a result. There are plenty of other ways to catch stupid criminals that don't carry the same risks. "worth it", "frequently", "risks" These are all numerical arguments but you're claiming it isn't about numbers. Set a value for risk and reward and drive for that policy. Don't make vague arguments that lean on statistics when it feels useful but refuse to say when something is worth it. What I see is kids getting shot in the street and my neighbors mugged and carjacked and police picking up guns in routine traffic stops. I don't think those are very "hypothetical".
- danenania 5y agoThat would only make sense if there was no other way to prevent these crimes. It's like asking for "numbers" to justify not putting every 16-25 year old male in prison. It would drastically reduce the crime rate! The numbers are: innocent people and police are dying needlessly, and any potential effect on the crime rate could also be achieved without those people dying through better policing strategies. It's pure waste.
- thatcat 5y agoThe amount of property stolen by police using civil forfeiture exceeds the amount stolen in property crime. On average, the risk of abuse exceeds the rewards of enforcement.
- josephcsible 5y agoAre you counting everything seized through civil forfeiture as being stolen? A lot of it really is drug dealer profits.
- thatcat 5y agoThat's the unproven assumption made about any cash. There was a choice made between regulation of most black markets and using their existance as a justification for legalizing theft.
- 0x737368 5y agoHow is stopping a car that's breaking road laws lead to someone getting killed?
- gus_massa 5y agoWould you be happy if this random search is extended to homes? What about a lottery every morning where they pick some random point in the map and they go to the home and make a search? What about searching homes because they have a broken light in the porch?
- colechristensen 5y agoIt's not a random search, it's people running lights and speeding getting stopped and it seems the kinds of people who are in the streets committing crimes that actually hurt people have a tendency to not obey traffic laws.
- danenania 5y agoEven if that's true, the percentage of people who commit traffic violations that are violent criminals is still extremely small, making it effectively a random search. People who commit crimes are probably more likely to get parking tickets too. Should police search the homes of everyone who gets a parking ticket since there's a slightly increased chance they'll find evidence of a crime by doing that?
- 0x737368 5y agoYep, this guy solved it - let's let all our streets devolve to Mumbai roads level madness because apparently it's unfair for police to stop cars for such "minor" infractions such as speeding.
- danenania 5y agoI said they should send fines through the mail instead of stopping people for minor things. How does that lead to "madness"? If anything the deterrent would be even stronger since police could give more fines if they didn't have to waste so much time pulling people over.
- 5y ago
- thatcat 5y agoNah, it's not worth it, the road side is not the place to fill out a form.