4 ms·
Under what circumstances exactly would it be a safety or security issue to replace one genuine OEM part with another genuine OEM part, identical in all ways exc
by josephcsible 5y ago
Under what circumstances exactly would it be a safety or security issue to replace one genuine OEM part with another genuine OEM part, identical in all ways except for the serial number?
- loopback_device 5y agoPerhaps to prevent (or at least make it harder for) someone shorting around the security it is supposed to provide, i.e. by emulating or modifying the replacement part - not that that'd really stop the determined ones
- Zak 5y agoIt's a safety issue to replace some, but not all of the cells in a Li-ion battery with cells that are not the same age and condition. Since smartphone batteries are almost always a single cell, it's a non-issue. Another scenario I can imagine is a charge controller reducing the maximum charging current as the battery ages based on information stored in the controller's memory, which would be incorrect if the cell is replaced. Of course, it would be unusual to replace a cell with one in worse condition, so it would also be surprising for that to be a safety concern.
- gambiting 5y agoKeep in mind that the check done inside an iPhone doesn't prevent the failure mode you describe. After all the phone only checks the microcontroller attached to the battery, not the actual cells(if that's even possible in any way).
- Zak 5y ago> not the actual cells(if that's even possible in any way). It isn't, but there are some controller circuits that switch off permanently if the voltage falls out of range, making changing cells more difficult.
- xondono 5y agoIt wouldn’t, OEM batteries can be swapped with no issues, it’s non-genuine parts what causes issues.
- l4yao 5y agoOn iPhone 12 and moreso on 13, many genuine OEM parts cannot be swapped by anyone other than those authorized by Apple.
- xondono 5y agoAFAIK, that’s only the case for the screen, and there’s a warning when swapping the rear camera.
- l4yao 5y ago(Some) Functionality is also lost on the front camera, faceid sensor and battery.
- philliphaydon 5y agohttps://youtu.be/8s7NmMl_-yg https://youtu.be/8s7NmMl_-yg It’s not just a warning. Functionality is flat out disabled. Swapping parts between 2 iPhone 13s boinks them.
- theranger 5y agoIt would not be a safety issue indeed only until the replacement part includes some mitm hardware that tampers the face id authentication flow. And this can be planted into the genuine looking replacement part as well.
- josephcsible 5y agoI expect that at least one of these things would have to be true: 1. The MITM hardware could be installed into the screen that's already paired with the iPhone, so the serial check wouldn't help 2. The MITM hardware would make the screen look non-genuine regardless of serial, so the serial check wouldn't be needed