5 ms·
It doesn't matter what will be dominant in 10 years. What matters for phones being bought today is what's dominant today.
by josephcsible 5y ago
It doesn't matter what will be dominant in 10 years. What matters for phones being bought today is what's dominant today.
- Retric 5y agoBut we aren’t really talking about today we are asking about what happens when a new phone shows up without it. You don’t need to sell to everyone on day one they just need to erode dominance fast enough that it doesn’t stop adoption.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> we are asking about what happens when a new phone shows up without it Nobody buys it. Do Linux phones have access to WhatsApp? If not, there is no point. It will be a perfectly good mobile computer but it will never actually replace the one in my pocket. And that's coming from a programmer who loves Linux. Imagine the utter disdain normal people would have for a phone that doesn't even run WhatsApp.
- m4rtink 5y agoWhatsapp used to be openly hostile against efforts for providing native client applications even for platforms they never plan to support themselves. Going as far as effectively attacking open source project developers working the clients - for an example see: https://reviewjolla.blogspot.com/2014/10/got-banned-in-whatsapp.html?m=1 https://reviewjolla.blogspot.com/2014/10/got-banned-in-whats... (Sailfish OS is a Linux based mobile distro.)
- matheusmoreira 5y agoThat sucks. I hate when companies do this. How would they even know what kind of client is talking to their servers?
- m4rtink 5y agoSome sort of undefined behavior or possibly some per build random key that triggers imposter warning if the third party app fails to send the correct key ? In any case totally evil behavior from their side. Its already bad enough they run totally proprietary centralized service with no public API & ignore any non-mainstream mobile platforms. But when they start banning users of third party clients on those platforms and go after third party client developers with presumably legal treats - that's pure evil, no way around it.
- 2cb 5y agoA Linux phone could run WhatsApp if the Linux distro was implemented in such a way that it could run Android apps (remember Android is basically just a runtime on top of the Linux kernel) and since AOSP is FOSS this is very doable and legal. How commercially successful it'd be is still a different story, but it could run WhatsApp.
- josephcsible 5y agoOnly if WhatsApp never activates SafetyNet: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28731431 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28731431
- 2cb 5y agoWhatsApp has no motivation to use SafetyNet. For one thing plenty of their users use cheap Chinese phones that aren't actually Google certified (but come with the Play Store anyway) and they know this full well from their analytics. For another, SafetyNet is used primarily for DRM on streaming services and for banking or other financial apps. Absolutely no messenger uses it that I am aware of (unless you count Snapchat as a "messenger" but that's literally it). Every FB owned app runs fine on Android devices that fail SafetyNet. No reason to believe that'll change because where's the benefit for FB?
- josephcsible 5y ago> unless you count Snapchat as a "messenger" I do, and it's pretty popular, so I don't think you should discount it so quickly.