6 ms·
I'm reminded of MySQL. "You don't have transaction support" "Sure we do - just handle it in your code" "But I need transactions" "No you don't! That's just ov
by mgkimsal 15y ago
I'm reminded of MySQL.
"You don't have transaction support"
"Sure we do - just handle it in your code"
"But I need transactions"
"No you don't! That's just overarchitecting!"
"No really I do"
"Look how fast we are!"
... years later...
"Hey look at MySQL - We have transactions! Look how great we are!"
etc.
I like FF. I use it. But every time there's some comment about FF memory, we usually see a bunch of people coming out saying they never see FF memory issues, the OP must be doing something wrong or have a bad system, they use their computer non-stop for 4 years without ever even seeing FF slow down, etc. Then endless discussion about "how can you even function having more than 2 tabs open? I always close all mine because of some cognition study from 1974 which I read in my one open tab, then closed it".
Now many of those same people will be spouting how great FF is because they've cut memory usage so much (and maybe how they'll venture in to the brave new world of 3-tabs-at-a-time).
End of the day, this is just how computer stuff goes - deny there's a problem, fix it, then promote how great your fix is. Just gets a bit tiresome.
Oh, and yes, I set up a bunch of strawmen up there. I love the smell of them burning in the morning.
- onemoreact 15y agoYou often see the same pattern with OS. User4,27,128: "I think there might be an issue." Fanboy37,652: "What are you talking about? This is the best thing ever!!!" Fanboy23,418: "That easy to fix, just type everything backward while singing and it all works fine!!1!" ... Dev15: "Fixed problem 4,129" Fanboy37,652: "Now that that's fixed, this is the best thing ever!!1!"
- jmillikin 15y ago> I like FF. I use it. But every time there's some comment > about FF memory, we usually see a bunch of people coming > out saying they never see FF memory issues, the OP must be > doing something wrong or have a bad system, they use their > computer non-stop for 4 years without ever even seeing FF > slow down, etc. That's because complaints about large memory use in Firefox fall into two camps, generally: 1. "I left Firefox on overnight with three tabs open, and now it's using 3.1 GiB of memory. This browser is terrible! Yes, I do have dozens of low-quality extensions installed, so?" 2. "I started Firefox, and already it's using over 300 MiB! That's insane! Why would a web browser ever use that much? I'm switching to Chrome, it only uses 100 MiB. What do you mean, 'multiple processes'?" There may in fact be genuine issues buried somewhere in the discussion, but they're hard to discern against the general background noise. > Then endless discussion about "how can you even function > having more than 2 tabs open? I always close all mine > because of some cognition study from 1974 which I read in > my one open tab, then closed it". You're getting confused between Firefox and Chrome. Firefox has always been the browser of choice for the "tons of tabs" crowd, because Chrome's process-per-tab model breaks down when there's more than a few dozen open. For example, I have just over 70 tabs open right now, Firefox has been running for about a month, and it's at 1.1 GiB resident memory. Chrome becomes very unhappy under such circumstances (since it uses about ~100 MiB per tab), so I'm careful to only open a few tabs at a time.
- crikli 15y ago> I have just over 70 tabs open... I'm really curious about this as once I get to about 10 tabs my brain starts wanting to close them to get back to something it can manage. This is either because I'm dumb (highly likely) or because you have a different usage style than I (also likely). So if you don't mind elaborating, how do you get to where you have that many tabs open?
- webspiderus 15y agoas a potentially different use case, I use my tabs as a stack for reading things (where I push a link when I see it), and will then read through them all in a serial fashion, closing things I'm 'done' with. this generally leads to me having reference and 'to read' tabs open, in addition to things I like to have on hand (i.e. emails, workflowy, HN). this generally adds up to 15-20 tabs in my main window on average, going up to as much as 30-40.
- carussell 15y agoThat's interesting. Because every time I've seen Mozilla developers making note of memory improvements over the last few years, I run into someone claiming that every time "Firefox" and "memory usage" came up prior to whichever is current for the time, the developers steadfastly denied a problem. It's getting a bit like the mythical proslytizing vegan; I've run into far more people bitching about however many instances of fuss-making by however many hostile vegans than I have of actual hostile vegans. (The count of the latter can be described as "basically none".)
- carussell 15y agoChallenges?
- mgkimsal 15y agofor me it wasn't developers specifically, it was just vocal users. i've not seen much from mozdevs at all contemporaneously with the discussions.
- carussell 15y ago> deny there's a problem, fix it, then promote how great your fix is I can't think of a way this can be construed as an indictment against vocal users, or really, anyone except the developers (or marketing or management from the same organization).
- bzbarsky 15y ago> we usually see a bunch of people coming out None of whom are actually active Firefox or Gecko developers... In other words, fanboys act like fanboys. Surprise!