6 ms·
FTA: They admit to being completely baffled about why the mamba would produce it. I would guess it keeps their target calm. A panicking prey is more likely to
by Someone 5y ago
FTA: They admit to being completely baffled about why the mamba would produce it.
I would guess it keeps their target calm. A panicking prey is more likely to injure the snake than one that dies before it realizes it got seriously bitten.
- _hilro 5y agoI would guess it's just a genetic glitch and not some conscious decision or purposeful design.
- daveguy 5y agoIt doesn't have to be a conscious decision or purposeful design to be "there for a reason". Evolution tends toward solutions because the population that happens to be closer to a solution are more likely to survive. Nothing the op said was incompatible with evolution.
- alisonkisk 5y agoEvolution doesn't have "reasons" (pre hoc is random mutation) but it has "justifications" (post hoc is natural selection).
- samhw 5y agoIn addition to that, it's certainly not a 'glitch'. A genetic glitch would be a (possibly short-lived) mutation which is still in the 'beta' phase, so to speak, or else a harmful side effect of an otherwise beneficial mutation (e.g. albinism). This is a paradigmatic example of an ordinary useful mutation which persisted because it increased fitness.
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y ago>> FTA: They admit to being completely baffled about why the mamba would produce it. It's because they are scientists. Scientists are always "baffled", in the news.
- wwweston 5y ago"the mind that is not baffled is not employed the impeded stream is the one that sings" -- Wendell Berry
- nyokodo 5y agoThat’s a simple and lovely poem that speaks to me deeply. Thanks for teaching me it exists.
- cheese_van 5y agoA snake, you see, Has no legs to flee. When frightened He does not dither, He slithers. (high school poet me, neither lovely nor deep, but I can't help myself)
- wwweston 5y agoBerry's a good well for deep-speaking thought. The essay from which it comes is pretty great too -- I don't think it's online in whole form but there are pieces discussed here: https://www.brainpickings.org/2014/11/18/wendell-berry-poetry-marriage/ https://www.brainpickings.org/2014/11/18/wendell-berry-poetr...
- 0xB31B1B 5y agoVery frustrating. In practice the scientists are expressing uncertainty “we do no know/need to investigate further” not confusion or bewilderment
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y agoI can imagine the journalists asking them "are you completely baffled?".
- raverbashing 5y agoYeah for real this is a major issue in news and science communication. There's "we don't know" (and we have no idea why), there's "we don't know" (just because we didn't prove it yet, but our money is on that) or (we think it's because so and so but haven't looked into it) and in-betweens.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> being completely baffled about why the mamba would produce it Is it delivered in a dose sufficient to cause unconsciousness, or even just euphoric lethargy in its prey? If so, that sounds both effective and weirdly sweet, given nature's usual barbarism.
- DamnYuppie 5y agoI am continually frustrated by and fail to understand how people can actually believe nature is barbaric. Nature is nature, it is kill or be killed, that is actually the natural order of things. Outside of that is an anomaly reserved for those at the absolute apex of power. This power was accumulated by being incredibly adaptable and observant. Both of these qualities made our ancestors very very good at killing things.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> frustrated by and fail to understand how people can actually believe nature is barbaric. Nature is nature, it is kill or be killed, that is actually the natural order of things. Barbaric literally means primitive and unsophisticated. (Sophistication referring to knowledge and culture.) When we say something is barbaric, we mean it is in its natural, unrefined, untouched-by-civilisation state. That might make the statement "nature is barbaric" seem tautologic. But your reaction exposes its meaning. The natural state of things, the barbaric state, is on we strive to escape. It is painful and suffering. Sometimes cruel. Enough to have motivated our species to seek to not be subject to it. To be free of the "natural order of things" by developing our knowledge, culture and civilization. As you mention, this often involved killing. But killing need not be painful and cruel.
- samhw 5y ago> Barbaric literally means primitive and unsophisticated This makes for the foundation of a nice story, but no, that's not what 'barbaric' means. It's not what you'll find in any dictionary, and it's not what the root of the word is. Barbaros, in Greek, referred to non-Greeks, with an early connotation of foreignness. It picked up a connotation of cruelty and savageness as early as the Romans. Any dictionary since then will give a primary meaning of cruelty and savagery, not just 'primitive and unsophisticated'. (Finally, my eight years of Ancient Greek at school comes in slightly handy!)