7 ms·
Even when the only possible "consumer goods" was a rock, there were luxury rocks. "What were they used for?" is asked like there's only one answer. They were p
by h2odragon 5y ago
Even when the only possible "consumer goods" was a rock, there were luxury rocks.
"What were they used for?" is asked like there's only one answer. They were probably used for anything else a rock is useful for, but being nicely sized for a hand, pretty, etc made them easier to use, more effective, or just flashier.
AFAIK the class of objects referred to here don't share a lot of qualities that would make them a class in other contexts; there's no single shape, some have wear that may indicate original uses, etc etc. It just appears to be some of the early personal artifacts that people valued that are durable enough to see today.
- cloudking 5y agoNow we have valuable digital rocks https://etherrock.com/ https://etherrock.com/ Full circle?
- edoceo 5y agoOh, that's not a joke.
- taylorfinley 5y agoNo, some of the rarest rocks in the world, several of which have sold for over $2.5 million. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EtherRock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EtherRock
- progre 5y agoAll my kids have brought home rocks that were deemed special in some way when they where about 5 years old . I guess at that age we somehow start to get around the idea of "owning" things in a more involved way, and it feels nice to have something special, like a nice round rock. Maybe stonage kids felt that way too.
- h2odragon 5y agoMy child is a teen now. The last time I said to her, "hey i found this cool rock, you want it?" was last week :)
- 123pie123 5y agoI still like looking at nice interesting rocks or pebbles and I'm way older than a teenager finding the pure white and very black ones and arranging them in patterns or matching piles is some what interesting* *when I'm forced to go to a beach and told to enjoy myself for hours on end whilst looking after the kids
- pengaru 5y agoThere's a rock shop in Joshua Tree that regularly has a line out the door on weekends, or at least did pre-pandemic.
- anonporridge 5y agoIt's probably an evolutionary adaptation. Whenever we humans find something unique or special, we either take it and store it somewhere safe or mark it on a map. The prehistoric individuals who did that would be more likely to happen to have just the right thing for surprise challenges. They would then have an advantage over those who didn't care about special things, because by definition they're hard to come by. And those surprise challenges often have asymmetric upside for those who have a solution, because everyone else is desperate for a solution or because they can solve the problem drastically more efficiently than everyone else. At the same time, mundane things aren't worth collecting because it's easy for anyone to go out and get it, so there exists no advantage for the collector. Therefore, if individuals who collected rare things ended up with more resources, power, and the resulting reproductive success, it also makes sense that young humans would do the same early on and that collecting rare things regardless of their utility is one of the most important status signals.
- h2odragon 5y agoI will tell my wife, next time she asks, that my pile of electronic junk will lead to us and our offspring having "more resources, power, and the resulting reproductive success." Wish me luck.
- anonporridge 5y agoRIP your penis, player.
- SamPatt 5y agoIn our current society being technologically adept probably does get you more luck with women over a lifetime than most professions. While a hoard of electronics may not have an instant connection to status like a fancy car, it's probably correlated to other attributes which are rapidly become more more valued.
- anonporridge 5y ago
- INTPenis 5y agoEven today people collect nice looking rocks, or minerals even. And I know that poor people would leave pebbles at altars when doing pilgrimage. So is it really so far fetched to say that these rocks were tactile enough for someone to keep them?
- Zuider 5y agoThey are all roughly spherical, so they could be cooking stones. Heated in a fire, they can be then rolled into a pit which contains the food and water, allowing the food to be boiled slowly without burning. https://www.thoughtco.com/stone-boiling-ancient-cooking-method-172854 https://www.thoughtco.com/stone-boiling-ancient-cooking-meth...
- gerdesj 5y ago"Also, most of the 20 balls that have been found in the Orkney Islands are carved and etched with patterns and designs. These, on the other hand, were polished smooth." It seems that these orbs are "complicated". A cooking stone as you describe is unlikely to be decorated. Do you inscribe your kettle! I have never heard of a quern being decorated either.
- heavyset_go 5y agoMajor religions and people of the past found great significance in their food and sources of food, so I wouldn't find it strange that significance and ornamentation would be applied to what's used to prepare that food.
- h2odragon 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quern-stone#Ornament_and_inscription https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quern-stone#Ornament_and_inscr... Grain millers had fierce debates about what patterns worked best on what stones and for which grains. some grooves are of great functional benefit, but then beyond that ...
- ganonm 5y agoTo provide some contemporary evidence to support your hypothesis that there were "luxury rocks" and that humans would be interested in such things, here is a gallery of various skins for a handheld rock in the videogame Rust. One of them costs $68 https://rust.esportinfo.gg/skins/tools/rock https://rust.esportinfo.gg/skins/tools/rock Humans haven't changed all that much since the Neolithic...
- asdfge4drg 5y ago"What were they used for?" is asked like there's only one answer. - the author literally goes to lengths to explain that they believe they had multiple purposes at different places/times. It's like you didn't actually read the article...
- dirkt 5y ago> Even when the only possible "consumer goods" was a rock Lots of other "consumer goods" made of more perishable materials just do not have survived...