5 ms·
A tangent: I’m learning piano and musical notation finally clicked for me. Musical notation is a high level language. It gives you a program that you can run o
by Waterluvian 5y ago
A tangent: I’m learning piano and musical notation finally clicked for me.
Musical notation is a high level language. It gives you a program that you can run on any instrument. And it gives you the ability to modify it with relative ease.
When playing clarinet in high school I felt that notion is this archaic thing that we’re stuck with because of the morons in the past. But I’m realizing it’s this beautifully refined language, developed over centuries.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoIt might be refined and developed over centuries, but it's also the expression of overwhelmingly a single culture. Western musical notation is not useless for denoting the music of other cultures, but it's also not very good and is frequently quite bad. If you think of western musical notation as "the system", you're at risk of remaining ignorant of the beautifully refined languages, developed over centuries, in other cultures. It's also a highly abstract language that seems to frequently, somewhat like Javascript, lead its users to have very little familiarity with what is going on at lower levels.
- kansface 5y agoAs a classical guitarist, western notation is not particularly good at expressing the music our own culture. The high open E string can be and is regularly played on the other 5 strings too, potentially at the same time! Natural and artificial harmonics, which string to play on and which fingers to use, and all sorts of right hand notation all feel very much bolted on cluttering the actual score. The continual coming and going of voices due to technical limitations means that music has to be experimentally decoded with much backtracking.
- interfixus 5y agoThey tried to teach me various instruments when I was a boy. I didn't mind the playing, but Lord Almighty how I hated the notation stuff. It simply made no sense whatever, and was - as you describe it - clearly invented by morons. Only when I ventured into tech-land in my teenage years did any of it finally click: So that's what they mean by 'octave' - a doubling of frequency. Why couldn't they just have said so? Harmonies, chords, what have you - it was all just frequencies and sine waves. Didn't musicians know anything? These many years later, I still don't quite get it, but do of course realise there must be some sort of point to it all. High level language? Yes, I get it. Bach wrote in Python, not C. Time to revisit.
- nautilius 5y agoYou can’t quite run it on different hardware: unlike on a piano, the note does not uniquely determine how something is played on, say, a guitar.
- moehm 5y agoWhat are some troubles guitarists are having with musical notation?
- imperistan 5y agoThe same note can be found on different strings. Sheet music doesn’t tell you which one to play. That just one example that makes it hard
- moehm 5y agoOn a piano, musical notation doesn't tell you which finger or hand you should use. This seems similar. Just for clarification, I asked because GP said: > You can’t quite run it on different hardware: unlike on a piano, the note does not uniquely determine how something is played on, say, a guitar.
- nautilius 5y agoIt’s not similar, because it doesn’t even tell you where to put the finger of your choice in a guitar, whereas that is uniquely specified on a piano. Of course, on top of that, you also have a wide range of ways to modify how you play on a guitar.
- moehm 5y agoI still don't see the point. If you practice a piece, you have to practice how to put which finger where, on a piano or a guitar. It's part of practicing to figure this out. > Of course, on top of that, you also have a wide range of ways to modify how you play on a guitar. Yeah, same with the piano. And I think, with most of all instruments.
- Finnucane 5y agoOn the clarinet you’ve got that awkward break at the twelfth so the registers have different fingering patterns. Piano notation seems to be mocking you. Now I play the banjo, where a number of open tunings are commonly used, which allows fast rhythms with minimal fretting.