3 ms·
> Wikipedia as usual has a decent overview IMO, it always reads decently, but I never know what is missing and what parts are accurate.
by wolverine876 5y ago
> Wikipedia as usual has a decent overview
IMO, it always reads decently, but I never know what is missing and what parts are accurate.
- dredmorbius 5y agoOffering a superior reference would be more substantive than making vague unsubstantiated assertions of innacuracy.
- wolverine876 5y agoIt's up to the person making the claim (in the GGP) to substantiate what they say, not up to others to disprove it. Otherwise, misinformation and disinformation (being intentional misinfo) have a field day - just keep posting and leave it to others to spend the time and do the work. It's a well known tactic for disinformation - the people telling the truth can't keep up. And look at the Internet - mis/disinfo is having a field day.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- effingwewt 5y agoI don't think the person you are replying to was saying that this was for sure an instance, but it definitely pays to view even Wikipedia with a critical eye. Wikipedia has gatekeepers and wikilawyers that keep highly contested/popular and even some niche pages from being altered even with sources. Many have been through it, it happened to me.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIt's still more useful to identify specific errors, and point to a better source. Wikipedia isn't perfect, yes, but it's been repeatedly show to be quite good. In particular, it synpsizes longer-term stories well, in ways that the news media often fail to (e.g., neither the linked NYT article nor its earlier expose, despite their length, both of which I'd read before linking Wikipedia). For the purposes of identifying the basic outlines of the ex-parrot^Wcompany, the passage I've quoted is helpful in esablishing when the firm began operations, etc. Again, I had no information going in. The meta-discussion of Wikipedia's accurac without identifying specific issues does little for any readers of this thread. It didn't with the first comment on that topic, and it continues to be the case. I'm done.
- effingwewt 5y agoMore useful is a bullshit metric. You seemed to take all of this as an attack against you personally, I assure you it was not, please calm down. No one said there was a better source, only that Wikipedia is far from perfect. No specifics need be given Wikipedia when its a truism that Wikipedia can be edited by anyone. Nevertheless here[1] is a page from Wikipedia about the reliability of Wikipedia. And since you are asking for specifics as if none exist, here[2] is an HN thread about issues with Wikipedia in which many examples and specifics are given. Now I, too, am done. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_is_not_a_reliable_source https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_is_not_a.... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21699011 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21699011
- effingwewt 5y agoReplying to myself since an article[1] even worse than those I posted hit HN 10/09/2021 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28808516 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28808516
- gremloni 5y agoThat’s what the citations and references are for.
- wolverine876 5y agoCitations and references are better than nothing, but they are limited: * You need to spend time: First you must find the source; what is provided in Wikipedia often is a dead link, or a book, or something else inaccessible. Then you have to read it; it can take time to find the spot in the entire source that supports the statement. It might require analysis and interpretation (I've often seen claims that relied on shoddy interpretation of evidence), including of the context and the quality of the source. And finally, if the source doesn't support the claim (which I've seen many times) it takes even longer - proving a negative, that the evidence doesn't exist, requires reading the entire source with some care. * Citations and references don't tell you when important information is omitted. For example, I could write that President X promised reform, in detail, and provide citations; I could easily omit that X had promised reform every year for five years and never delivered. I could write that Adam punched Bob and cite it, and omit that Bob punched Adam first. Another way of saying it: Accuracy is defined in some domains as Correct, Complete, and Consistent. Wikipedia is often (not always) Correct in what it says, but not Complete or Consistent.