3 ms·
Belowground is often better, and was widely used, but then you have to arrange water drainage for the hole, or the ice or groundwater soaks your straw (Zimri-Li
by kragen 5y ago
Belowground is often better, and was widely used, but then you have to arrange water drainage for the hole, or the ice or groundwater soaks your straw (Zimri-Lim didn't have styrofoam). On the side of a hill or in a sandy desert that's not too hard, but when you're digging below the water table this is a real problem if your sump pump is just a shadoof, and especially when tadelakt is the state of the art in waterproofing. Zimri-Lim may not have even had tadelakt, and he definitely didn't have waterglass, and possibly not enough pitch or tar to waterproof a whole icehouse. Almanzo Wilder's childhood icehouse was (if the novel is accurate on this point) actually up on stilts, presumably to guarantee drainage.
(Stationary air outside a wall adds a little more insulance that dirt won't, even dry dirt, but I think it's too small to matter in this context.)
It's desirable to store your ice well below 0°, as you say, but if the only thing you have to cool it with is ice, you don't have a choice; you can fill your icehouse up with beautiful ice at -20° if you like, but its specific heat is only 2 kJ/kg/K, so after 40 kJ/kg leaks through your insulation it's all up to 0°. Avoiding this requires more than an order of magnitude more insulation than simply keeping the ice from melting before next winter: instead of 100 mm of straw you might be talking about 2 meters, or more if your icehouse is smaller than the humongous 10×10×10 cube I chose for calculational convenience. (This is also why icehouses were not useful for freezing, for example, meat, but only refrigerating it; consequently Argentina's economy didn't explode until 01883, because exporting fresh mutton and beef was impossible.)
You may be able to solve this problem by salting water, which can actually produce a mild refrigeration effect, but eutectic segregation may sabotage your efforts to do phase-change thermal energy storage that way; that's why I mentioned eutectic aqueous sylvite, which I think is the most suitable choice for solving that problem in modern solar-powered domestic freezers.