3 ms·
> Agree, and I think everyone here has experienced the phenomenon where someone on reddit/HN/twitter has explained something far better than a media outlet. I'
by ceejayoz 5y ago
> Agree, and I think everyone here has experienced the phenomenon where someone on reddit/HN/twitter has explained something far better than a media outlet.
I've experienced the opposite, though, too.
Posts with thousands upon thousands of upvotes and a little comment with a dozen saying "this is entirely wrong, and here's a bunch of proof, and here's an expert explaining it properly".
- prox 5y agor/Askscience is pretty good though more often than not. It depends a lot on which sub you are in.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoThat's not really the opposite. That comment with the correction is a part of the submission that's being upvoted. I do this myself, too: if the discussion underneath a HN submission rescues an otherwise bad article, or even develops into a completely unrelated but interesting tangent, I'll happily upvote it. Sometimes the only value of the submitted article is in the discussion it starts - but that still makes the particular submission valuable.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe correction often receives a minute fraction of the attention the parent post does.