Okay, since you're so hung up on this shorting as a reason to call the market a "scam". I hear some hedge funds owed stock, and held "synthetic" stock, in the

Okay, since you're so hung up on this shorting as a reason to call the market a "scam". I hear some hedge funds owed stock, and held "synthetic" stock, in the form of options, but did not hold the stock itself. Maybe some funds didn't even hold those! Let's assume all of this is truer than true and put it beyond dispute. It sounds a little dodgy, possibly a violation of contracts, possibly illegal. It also sounds like they lost a fair amount of money acquiring stock to cover their obligations, and it sounds like some retail investors were able to make money from the processes related to their need for this stock. So let's put this in perspective. If all of this is such a scam, tell me: who are the victims of this "scam?" Who precisely thought they owned stock, and found out that they did not in fact own stock, and lost some or all of their money? Does this person or legal entity actually exist? Where can we read a story of their woes as their stock evaporated? And if this is such a scam, how common is all this? We are discussing a very broad claim: "The stock market is a scam.... Don't fall for it." What saliency does the Gamestop story have to this claim? Tell me, sir: if I am an average investor, and I am investing $10,000 in the market, in the statistically average way that people invest, how many of these dollars will I expect to lose to a scam such as this one? On average? I hold that the answer is probably somewhere between $0.00 and $0.00. Oh, there are some very real scams and fraud out there on the market, but they tend to be more like Enron, or some firm like Theranos (except public) — not "failure to deliver shares" risk. And they're still a tiny risk to any index fund owner.