5 ms·
The web as it's understood by most people is about sharing messages, images, games, audio and video. Wasting time, having fun. So why does all talk of Web3 alw
by rchaud 5y ago
The web as it's understood by most people is about sharing messages, images, games, audio and video. Wasting time, having fun.
So why does all talk of Web3 always shoehorn in blockchain and smart contracts? Who cares about that besides crypto buyers, who are mostly conducting their business via clearweb exchanges anyway?
The best part of Web 1.0 era was that you didn't have to pay to access information beyond what your ISP charged. Ethereum and its dApps are pay-to-play. I'd be interested to know how many of the cited 7000 dApps offer free information, and not just overpriced digital trinkets.
- BrianOnHN 5y ago> how many of the cited 7000 dApps offer free information, and not just overpriced digital trinkets My guess is that number is zero. It would make no sense otherwise. No reasonable person would open a classic book store on Rodeo Drive. What's the difference?
- kvark 5y agoComputers 40 years ago, as understood by most people, would be giant calculators. Who cares about sound, graphics, portability, aside from a few nerds? It turns out, people will care, once they discover the new ways.
- verdverm 5y agoThose are small technical things and while blockchain has technology, it is more of a social change, which is harder and different. Blockchain is getting the heat social networks should have up front. There are sufficient bad actors that blockchain will be dangerous for most people's financial well being, like social networks are for most peoples mental well being.
- continuational 5y agoThat's a great argument - it works for any upcoming technology!
- rchaud 5y agoBut the web today already has graphics, sound, portability, etc. Web3 isn't offering anything beyond our current capabilities.
- M2Ys4U 5y ago>So why does all talk of Web3 always shoehorn in blockchain and smart contracts? Who cares about that besides crypto buyers, who are mostly conducting their business via clearweb exchanges anyway? Nobody - those are exactly the people who push "Web3" (which has little to do with the web) as they're in desperate need of a Greater Fool in order to realise their "investment" in cryptocurrency-related assets.
- edoceo 5y agoRight, one can do distributed/federated apps w/o blockchain (see email). It's too practical to be exciting
- WhisperingShiba 5y agoCrypto is ultimately going to prove to be a more efficient means of value exchange, and easier for developers to utilize that the current financial system. That alone is enough to make me feel sure of my investments. However, there are many beautiful things that will come out of Web3.0 as well. End to end open source VPNs, containerized and running on a decentralized cloud is already a reality. You an use it today for free on Android and IOS (Velocity VPN - Running Sentinel back end.) Its open source and anonymous end to end. No one is keeping logs. Don't look at the shit coins and the bubble and think the dream of Web3.0 is not real.
- tenebrisalietum 5y agoA blockchain doesn't necessarily have to be currency in the sense of something you use to buy and sell things. It's also a decentralized to store data that shouldn't change unless authorized by an owner (owner here = possessor of a private key). Namecoin is an example - a domain owner can update a name record whenever desired and as long as everyone is using the blockchain a centralized authority cannot prevent the owner from making changes, and a centralized authority cannot make changes the owner doesn't want without the owner's private key.
- cl0ne 5y agoRevolution Populi is another interesting project that is working on a decentralized database with user controls and an SDK for creating social networks. According to them, preliminary testing of their blockchain showed support for +100k transactions per second: https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1414962828335894536 https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1414962828335894536
- bko 5y ago> I'd be interested to know how many of the cited 7000 dApps offer free information, and not just overpriced digital trinkets. Blockchain is open by default. So all information is free. You can see who owns the trinkets, and the entire history of the trinkets from inception. You can't claim you "own" that trinket, but the information is free
- HelixEndeavor 5y agoFree information about overpriced digital trinkets, how amazing...
- sam0x17 5y ago> beyond what your ISP charged This is misleading. Very little on the internet is actually free. Right now (and back then) there is tons of content that is either paywalled or supported by advertising. I think by-in-large most people consume less "usage" than what they pay for with subscriptions, etc., and generate much more revenue via advertising for the sites they visit than the cost of the bandwidth they are consuming. Imagine if instead of being bombarded with ads or subscription CTAs, you are simply charged $0.00001 for your visit to [insert cool blog here], or $0.0001 per second of video you watch on [awesome youtube equivalent here]. That is the dream.
- sam0x17 5y agoIn this kind of web, it would also be quite possible for a single developer to run a site as big as Youtube without needing tons of up-front cost. Bandwidth is free from the perspective of the site developer, and doing some small finite amount of video conversion work for the network before your video starts playing could also be built into the smart contract. Not all problems scale well this way, but video conversion is embarrassingly parallel at the keyframe level AFAIK. Conversely, the site operator could just calculate the cost of running video conversions in AWS and spread this cost out to all users by increasing the page view fee slightly.
- acdha 5y ago> In this kind of web, it would also be quite possible for a single developer to run a site as big as Youtube without needing tons of up-front cost. Bandwidth is free from the perspective of the site developer, How would that work? Blockchains are far too inefficient to host video files and nobody is hosting that much data for free so you still need to set up a paid hosting environment or learn why P2P video hosting has failed every time it's been tried in the past. You can charge people to host their video, at which point you'll learn that it's really hard to compete with ad-supported hosting because the number of people who say they want to pay up front for their stuff and actually do so is a rounding error of the number of users a major video site will have.
- 5y ago
- mark_l_watson 5y agoAh, the term "Web 3.0". I wrote a Ruby book with "Web 3.0" in the title, which to me is semantic web and linked data added to "Web 2" many years ago, and I was disappointed how quickly the book's content quickly seemed irrelevant, even to me the author. I wish the NFT and blockchain enthusiasts better luck with the term than I had.
- visarga 5y agoUnrelated, but do you know where I can collect lots of semantic web schemas for research?
- mxmilkiib 5y agoHere is an unrefined set of links https://wiki.thingsandstuff.org/Semantic#Ontologies_.2F_vocabularies https://wiki.thingsandstuff.org/Semantic#Ontologies_.2F_voca...
- hammyhavoc 5y agoWow, Scripting Intelligence?!
- mark_l_watson 5y agoYes, that is the book. I was so excited when I was writing that book, but I received very little feedback from readers (a metric for evaluating my writing) compared to other books I wrote. After writing that book for Apress (a wonderful publisher to work with, BTW), my 10th book with traditional publishers, I switched to writing eBooks on leanpub. This is more fun, since I can write about very niche topics and I can instantly update books with bug fixes and new material. Off topic, but writing is a lot of fun, and I never work with people who I don’t try to talk into writing at least one book.