3 ms·
Your scheme of public keys on websites only works for the Taylor Swifts of the world once they’ve become Taylor Swift. It depends heavily on the social capital
by ashtonkem 5y ago
Your scheme of public keys on websites only works for the Taylor Swifts of the world once they’ve become Taylor Swift. It depends heavily on the social capital of websites verifying identity, a system that is pretty useless for new artists.
This is roughly as practical as pgp key parties were: not practical at all. What are you going to do, go manually check the signing key on every artists website before doing some NFT transaction with them? Crypto already has a UX problem, don’t make it worse!
> A lot of NFTs forego the physical court enforcement over IP. In the same way that fake Luis Vuitton purses don't devalue the original, it's largely ignored. It's still quite possible to find free MP3s on torrents, but the vast majority of people nowadays just use streaming services because it's official and they want to support their favorite artists with revenue. Same will go with NFTs.
You can interpret this in one of two ways.
1) NFTs are completely incapable of managing royalties, so they don’t matter.
2) Things wildly unrelated to NFTs do royalties way better, so it doesn’t matter.
Neither is a good argument for NFTs, as they tacitly admit that NFTs are incapable of doing royalties at all.
- chrisco255 5y agoNonsense. Crypto has reputation systems just like everywhere else. I just shipped a successful NFT art project this week with a team. We already made our first 1.5ETH royalty payment from OpenSea in the first 24 hours (although they only pay out once a month, we managed to launch just a day before the cut off). It works absolutely fine.
- panabee 5y agowhat did you use to create the art project, if you don’t mind sharing? re the criticism above, why couldn’t opensea or NFT marketplaces perform verification for you and display twitter-like checkmarks for art sold by owner?
- panabee 5y agothanks for the comments. you thought a lot about this, and it’s helpful to hear skeptical arguments. why couldn’t opensea or NFT marketplaces perform verification for you and display twitter-like checkmarks for art sold by owner?