3 ms·
I am surprised by the many naysayers. Not because I think that his thoughts are necessarily the solution but because the lack of constructive criticism. First
by ThomPete 15y ago
I am surprised by the many naysayers.
Not because I think that his thoughts are necessarily the solution but because the lack of constructive criticism.
First of all I didn't read the post to say "this is to solution to end all solutions" but rather here is an idea could it work.
Second how is this a top down approach in any classical sense? His claims is that the companies who think they can create jobs with more money, exist out there and he want the find a mechanism to find them instead of simply distributing at large across the system and see what happens.
Third the US is probably the best country in the world to be an entrepreneur and business. There is very little in the way for anyone to find a need and then go out and build a business around it and there is a huge market for that. If your claim is that it can only be solved by making that part easier then the entire premise of capitalism seems flawed (I don't believe it is and I am not saying you are claiming that either)
The problem fundamentally is that you can only adjust your metrics so far before they become meaningless.
The first step to get the US out of their debt is to raise taxes. That won't make the startup environment better but it will start showing that the US as a country are ready to pay their bills instead of speculating their way out of it.
And before you start calling me a socialist and other nasty things let me just pre-empt this by the following.
I live in Denmark, a country with a progressive tax system +55% tax for the highest incomes and a sales tax of 25%. A car here cost 3 times the amount of a car in the US all because of taxes.
I am a member of the only liberal (in the european sense) political party and is fighting to get lower taxes.
So I am not saying raise taxes lightly. I am simply saying that the US have reached a point where the low tax is working against them not for them.
All systems have thresholds especially economic ones. To keep wanting more of the same ends up creating a self sustaining effect after you reach a certain point. The US have reached that now.
- jswinghammer 15y agoHistorically the US federal government has never collected more than 20% of GDP in taxes. Doesn't really matter what the tax rates are. The US needs to get out of debt and I think ending wars is the way to do that.
- rgraham 15y agoThis is an important point. Raising taxes is not a static game either. There are a lot of ways people with money avoid taxes now. I think Cuban was right that we do have a spending problem. We spend too much on things that are not important. We should cut debt, but the debate around this issue has been framed as a false and confusing dichotomy by the two major political parties.
- ThomPete 15y agoEnding the war will cut onto spending but what are you going to do with all the soldiers out of a job. Don't forget that the military de facto works as social welfare. So you will have to figure out what to do with them. Someone have to pick up the bill and I have a hard time seeing who that could be besides the american taxpayers. And just because it hasn't been done before is obvious no natural law
- eru 15y ago> Ending the war will cut onto spending but what are you going to do with all the soldiers out of a job. The money that you save by not having a military, can go to buying other goods that those ex-soldiers can provide.