8 ms·
So code isn't the law? Why does anyone trust these systems that keep failing time after time? If they need to ask money back and really have poor recourse? Didn
by Ekaros 5y ago
So code isn't the law? Why does anyone trust these systems that keep failing time after time? If they need to ask money back and really have poor recourse? Didn't current banking and legal system to develop just solve those issues?
- drfxyjhdyfrhgc 5y ago>So code isn't the law? Code is law. This law was just written incorrectly. This is a known risk; it's the reason why defi interest rates are similar to junk bonds.
- automatic6131 5y agoYes, let's turn the [financial|legal](delete as appropriate) system into an obfuscated C competition. Last place prize is: [lose your life savings|spend life in prison].
- beambot 5y agoCurious. I would claim that our current finance and legal system frequently does the very same for the impoverished or disenfranchised... Underbanked get hammered by fees with no safety net for emergency expenses. And large portions of our population get saddled with poor legal representation resulting in de facto indentured survitude in for-profit prisons.
- pavel_lishin 5y agoThat's a fair criticism of the current system, but not a good justification for introducing another shitty, broken system as an alternative.
- sneak 5y agoYou don’t need a justification for giving people more choices that they’re free to ignore if they don’t like the terms or circumstances. More options are better. Nothing about DeFi or cryptocurrencies invalidates or prevents people from continuing to bank as usual. The whole alternative system is opt-in.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoI don’t understand why anyone, even an enthusiast, would dare to touch cryptocurrency lending with a forty-nine-and-a-half-foot pole. There’s no technical measure that can force me to pay back the coins I borrowed if I don’t have them. If you wanted to enforce being paid back in the real world legal system you’d be much better served with normal lending systems, know your customers, and report them to credit authorities. And if it’s not one of those “stablecoins” you’re borrowing something that could conceivably be worth 10x more in a year; that sounds like financial suicide. What do you possibly gain from engaging with all this? Maybe if I built a defi lending platform myself so I could take a lot of loans from my customers and then default. That’d work just fine. Otherwise, run for the hills.
- yokem55 5y agoBecause the only way to get a loan is to put up collateral that is locked into a contract. And that collateral can only be extracted if you pay back the loan. So, if you value the collateral less then your debt, then, sure, walk away. But if the value of that collateral falls to less then the liquidation threshold (an amount some percentage greater then the value of your debt), your debt will be paid back by a liquidation bot and the the liquidator will take your collateral for themselves.
- UncleMeat 5y agoThere is a huge problem with the collateral model: liquidity. If you put up $X in FOO_COIN as collateral and FOO_COIN starts tanking in value, the contract is supposed to auto-liquidate once it hits a certain point. But there is absolutely no guarantee that this can find a buyer. So the "guaranteed" collateral recovery is not exactly guaranteed.
- bhaak 5y agoHow is that different to traditional finance? Evergrande almost went belly-up as the prices of their real state fell sharply because they sold so much of it to cover their credits. The financial crisis from 2007 was because the collaterals were nowhere as sound as they were sold for. Don’t get me wrong I think it’s mostly a house of cards but crypto finance is just traditional finance on steroids IMO.
- sremani 5y agoIf Code is law, the compiler is the judge.
- canjobear 5y agoIf the code is the law how can it be incorrect? It can only be incorrect by comparison with some other law (like "the code writer's intentions"), in which case you are effectively making that the true authoritative law, rather than the code.
- SkipperCat 5y agoAnd that is the crux of the issue. Modern banking has tons of fees and burdensome regulations, but it also has entrenched layers of protection that makes sure both the bank and the customer are not 100% nuked when there is a problem. Bank runs like from the movie "Its a wonderful life" - they don't happen anymore. Currencies devaluating like an exploding balloon - not since the civil war. Sure, it costs you more, but it saves you more. Lotta benefits to crypto, but lots of hurdles need to be overcome (power and security for a start).
- iso1210 5y ago> Bank runs like from the movie "Its a wonderful life" - they don't happen anymore. Another example of a bank run is the bank run of Northern Rock on the 14th September 2007. This was the biggest banking problem in the United Kingdom since the banking crisis in the seventies, this was also the first bank run in the United Kingdom in 150 years. Eventually, this resulted in the nationalization of Northern Rock. It is interesting to analyze this bank run because it is one of the most recent bank runs in Western Europe. Furthermore, the bank run from Northern Rock is a special case because it was a ‘reversed bank run’. Normally during a bank run, a lot of depositors first withdraw their money, due to lack of confidence for example, and then the bank will as a result of the huge withdraws get into a liquidity crisis. However, in the case of Northern Rock, the bank first got into a liquidity crisis and as a result of that, depositors withdrew their money from the bank. https://arno.uvt.nl/show.cgi?fid=116241 https://arno.uvt.nl/show.cgi?fid=116241 It certainly looks like a bank run - the scenes in London today fulfilled the dictionary definition. And heading north to Nottingham, and Middlesbrough, the same extraordinary scenes. savers forming long queues to drain their life savings from Northern Rock. Banking -- an industry built on credibility, confidence and trust. But the Rock looks wrecked even in its home town of Newcastle. Deposit guarantees should prevent this. But even after an extraordinary unlimited lending facility granted by the Bank of England and agreed by the Chancellor, customers preferred the sight of real cash. https://www.channel4.com/news/articles/business_money/the%2Bnorthern%2Brock%2Bbank%2Brun/802462.html https://www.channel4.com/news/articles/business_money/the%2B...
- zinekeller 5y ago
- Tenoke 5y agoThat's like asking why people trust sites or banks after some sites or banks have had bugs. In neither case does it invalidate the whole concept.
- endisneigh 5y agono it's not
- wyager 5y agoCode hasn’t been law for “defi” since Ethereum reverted the DAO hack in 2016. Then the DAO went defunct later that year anyway!
- bhaak 5y agoNot “anyway“ but because of the hack. TheDAO was done for after it was hacked. The code was too bad and trust was gone as well. That was clear pretty soon. The only thing to decide was if they would let the hacker get away with at the time 15% of the whole supply. If they did that it would have endangered the decentralization of the eventual proof-of-stake switch.
- wyager 5y ago> it would have endangered the decentralization So they decided to kill it outright?
- bhaak 5y agoYou have to specify what kind of decentralization you're getting at. The distribution of ETH was less decentralized before the hard fork than afterwards. 15% of the whole supply in one hand is quite a concentration in the distribution.
- canjobear 5y ago> it would have endangered the decentralization So the solution to save "decentralization" was for a centralized cabal to literally rewrite history?
- bhaak 5y agoTechnically, there was no rewriting of history. Just a single (but very large) transaction was added to the consensus rules that (IIRC) replaced the TheDAO smart contract code. Given that this incident resulted in the Ethereum/Ethereum Classic split, the "centralized cabal" was not very effective. The community voted with their feet and many went to Ethereum Classic.
- xiphias2 5y agoWhile I'm not into Ethereum itself, lots of the failures you see are happening because the infrastructure for (mostly) decentralized finance is moving at an incredible (and irresponsible) speed. We're witnessing the modern version of old bank robberies that helped create the regulations.
- hda2 5y ago> So code isn't the law? Why does anyone trust these systems that keep failing time after time? If they need to ask money back and really have poor recourse? Didn't current banking and legal system to develop just solve those issues? As far as the crypto itself is concerned, of course it is. The issue here is that the founder is using another system to blackmail users. The fact that this founder had to resort to tactics like these (instead of reverting the mistake on his end) shows that these systems are working as advertised.