3 ms·
I find it crazy how many people are surprised by this label and even more how many people try to ridicule it or dismiss it by saying "why don't you just call it
by dustinmoris 5y ago
I find it crazy how many people are surprised by this label and even more how many people try to ridicule it or dismiss it by saying "why don't you just call it blah...", etc.
It's a cultural norm, and it isn't just a Chinese/Mandarin thing, this exists in many other cultures. In India they also have very different words for different relatives and it has long traditional reasons because historically it was (and even still is today) very important to keep good relationships with a big family network because quite frankly in many places life depends on it.
For example, if you have a sister and she gets married then you'd address your sister's husband's brother differently than if you also have a married brother. You wouldn't use the same word for your brother's wife's brother. Why? Well traditionally (and still today) if a women gets married then she leaves her family home and moves in with her in-laws. At that point she leaves one family and becomes the "daughter" of another family. She'll be living alongside her husband's siblings and his parents. As a brother you will address them differently and with respect because you want them to be good to your sister and because you are thankful that they are taking care of her now.
People should educate themselves more before making stupid comments because it really just shows their complete lack of worldliness, education, ignorance and arrogance. Not attributes which gain you a lot of respect in the world IMHO.
- wayneftw 5y agoThis is conflating two different issues. Nobody here has said that other cultures shouldn't have special designators for various family members. Some even knew the specific term for this one and the Chinese symbol for it. It's perfectly reasonable for programmers to ridicule an unwieldy symbol and offer a shorter replacement. The replacement was to use the same word that is used in that culture instead of trying to describe the concept in English. I don't see ignorance or arrogance in any of that.
- camtarn 5y agoObviously comment order changes, but I literally just needed to look one comment down to find somebody saying "This type of contact classification is useless", and there are a bunch of other similar comments scattered around. I think the GP poster has a good point.