5 ms·
> just like happened every other time in history a single government took over an entire area. Not sure why you think this, because, if anything, the opposite
by tsimionescu 5y ago
> just like happened every other time in history a single government took over an entire area.
Not sure why you think this, because, if anything, the opposite is true. Scientific and technical progress almost always arise from stable, wealthy, large societies. The Chinese empire was a leader of science theoughput much of its history. The Roman empire as well. The Arab Caliphates became bastions of science once it had conquered enough to have a massive stable area. The USA became a massive source of innovation after it had settled it's half of the continent.
The only major exception I know of for scientific progress in times of war (that is not simply weapons advancement) is the wake of WWII.
- danjac 5y agoThe early modern period - Renaissance, Enlightenment and Industrial Revolution - occurred among highly competitive, constantly warring European states.
- tsimionescu 5y agoThat's almost like rejecting my example of current US inventions (or at least those from 10 years ago) because the US is technically at war in Irak or Afghanistan. The Renaissance, Enlightenment and Industrial Revolution happened in the propsperous centers of those European countries, in cities that hadn't heard of conquest for a century or more. They were also often the result of international relationships between thinkers and artists across the continent. Competition surely provided some motivation for the Industrial Revolution, but it was not the main impetus, nor was it a major factor for the others.
- danjac 5y ago> The Renaissance, Enlightenment and Industrial Revolution happened in the propsperous centers of those European countries, in cities that hadn't heard of conquest for a century or more https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_Wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_Wars
- jokethrowaway 5y agoThere was still competition at that point. As soon as we have robots that perform as well as a human, whoever has resources can make whatever they need (soldiers, workers) and who doesn't have resources is disposable. There is no need to make concessions with disposable people demanding rights, you can just send killer robots and replace those people with robots.
- mrjangles 5y agoInteresting you would bring up China as it is the number one famous example of an empire stagnating for thousands of years. The Roman Empire is well known to have made all of it's huge technological advancements in the beginning when they were a smaller, anti elitist, working class society with an emphasis on property rights and freedom. Later it became the gigantic, corruption ridden empire of upper class orgies that it was famous for. All the wealth of scientific progress in Europe happened in the 18 hundreds after the french revolution invented the concept of Nationalism / freedom / and international trade and competition. These values disappeared from Europe in the 20th century, but were kept alive and well in the USA over that time period. Since then just about every single advancement and scientific discovery of any value has taken place in the USA. Just about everything you own was invented in America (your mass produced vehicle, internet -- no it wasn't invented at CERN -- optical fibers, almost all of your medicine, your computer techonology, your lcd screen ...everything), meanwhile nothing gets created in Europe anymore.