4 ms·
The president and Congress must recognize that an AA-plus country, to remain AA-plus, must focus on growth, not debt reduction, in the short term. +1 I tweete
by nl 15y ago
The president and Congress must recognize that an AA-plus country, to remain AA-plus, must focus on growth, not debt reduction, in the short term.
+1
I tweeted this a month ago: Dear America: A lack of growth, NOT spending caused your debt problem. Please Fix ASAP KTHX.[1]
That's a little simplistic (the joys of 140 chars). Of course spending caused problems, but it wasn't spending alone - it was spending combined with a lack of growth (and indeed negative growth at times).
What is more (and isn't explicitly called out in this article) is that economic growth can go a huge way to fixing the debt problem.
Growth->lower unemployment->less spending on welfare
Growth->higher tax receipts->increased debt repayment
[1] http://twitter.com/#!/nlothian/status/94266497513426944 http://twitter.com/#!/nlothian/status/94266497513426944
- nl 15y agobased on the downvotes, I guess my logic must be highly faulty..
- joelhaus 15y agoNo. You're exactly correct. Wrote a comment, directly related, on Google+ the other day in this thread: https://plus.google.com/107033731246200681024/posts/LHVVz5e3irj https://plus.google.com/107033731246200681024/posts/LHVVz5e3... Here it is (can't figure out how to link directly to a comment): -------------------------------------------------------------- I sort of blame this on shoddy journalism. There is actually broad bi-partisan consensus from economists and business on what policy steps need to be taken. There is an important ratio that is largely being ignored: Debt-to-GDP ~ This is a fundamental measurement for determining credit risk. ~ Economists agree this ratio will grow too high in the future. ~ Economists agree we must spark GDP growth in the present. ~ There are two ways to improve this ratio: (i) Shrink the debt (cut spending &/or raise taxes) (ii) Grow GDP (invest in economy &/or cut redtape for business) Both long and short-term concerns can be addressed by investing & tax breaks now, and legislating cuts & revenue for later. The question is how these should be balanced, but they will all help. Planet Money probably does a better job of explaining sovereign debt to GDP ratios in this recent podcast: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2011/07/20/138518262/the-tuesday-podcast-how-much-debt-is-too-much http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2011/07/20/138518262/the-tues...
- RuadhanMc 15y agoTo a certain extent debt is the problem. If the US and other Governments didn't have so much debt when the shit hit the fan in 2008 then they would have had more means to deal with the growth issues. US public debt is 100% debt to GDP, so there isn't a whole lot of room to move.
- nhaehnle 15y agoEmpirically, the case of Japan contradicts your claim that there isn't a whole lot of room to move. To remind you, Japan has long at close to and above a 200% debt-to-GDP ratio without any financing difficulty in sight. The underlying reason for that is plain and simple: both the Japanese and the US governments are currency issuers. By definition, they are able to spend as much money in their respective currencies as they like. In that sense, they always have an infinite amount of room to move. The only question can therefore be: How much of this maneuvering room should be used? The answer to that question does not lie in financial data alone, but must take into account the state of the economy at large and whether additional spending might hit an inflation barrier. In the current situation, spending directed towards job-creation is unlikely to hit such a barrier, while handing out more money to the rich could drive speculation on resource markets (the money will be "invested" somewhere, after all) that can cause price increases and thus inflation.
- RuadhanMc 15y agoIt's a fascinating situation. I don't claim to know the answer or how much debt is viable. I do agree that the US isn't in the same basket as other debt-laden countries. They are an exception -- but for how long... I don't know. I think there is a ceiling -- and I'm not talking about the official debt ceiling -- of debt. Is it 100% debt to GDP? 200%? 300%? It's somewhere. There's a point at which it just isn't possible to repay the money.
- nhaehnle 15y agoSorry for repeating myself, but the US government will always be able to repay the money. They are the ones who maintain the authoritative databases that contain the information about how many reserves the commercial banks have and who owns the debt. The only obligation associated with repaying the debt is to change an entry in the debt database, and do a corresponding change to an entry in the reserves database. Since the government maintains these databases, they will always be able to do that. There are a number of problematic things that might happen in the future. For example, if all the owners of the debt suddenly decided to go on a spending spree, then they might cause some (heightened, but non-hyper) inflation if the economy simply isn't able to produce enough real goods and services to fulfill the increased demand. Then politics has a choice of either weathering the inflation or raising taxes to fight it, and there might be other tough choices of equity and social justice involved. But the ability to repay the money simply cannot be an issue, and nobody can accurately predict whether any of those other problems will ever happen.