3 ms·

I'm not a professional musician but I'm classically trained in piano and violin. I listened to the "selection" at the bottom and it really makes absolutely no m

by dheera 5y ago

I'm not a professional musician but I'm classically trained in piano and violin. I listened to the "selection" at the bottom and it really makes absolutely no musical sense at all. The phrasing is off, it seems like someone just regurgitated phrases from several different pieces and put them together. It does not carry a coherent theme, and very abruptly switches styles several times with no good transitions at all, and transitions was something Beethoven was truly a master at. And at 1:30 WTF in the hell was that?

mstade 5y ago
I couldn't play an instrument if my life depended on it, can't sing particularly well and also have little to no musical training beyond whatever we did in middle school – even I can tell this piece just doesn't sound right. Listening to it felt schizophrenic or something, like it's reaching all over the place and just going off on weird incoherent tangents. Almost exhausting to try and keep up with it, and not in a good way.