7 ms·
> Scarcity is fundamental to any store of value. There are an infinite number of potential NFTs. I'm a pretty big crypto-skeptic, and I'm especially an NFT ske
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
> Scarcity is fundamental to any store of value. There are an infinite number of potential NFTs.
I'm a pretty big crypto-skeptic, and I'm especially an NFT skeptic, but this is a weird argument. It's kind of like saying there could be an infinite number of paintings, so why should Picassos be worth very much? Even more, it's possible to create extremely high quality reproductions of famous Picasso paintings, but they would have just a teeny amount of value of the original.
Reason being, with very expensive art, and other things like a signed book or baseball card, what you're really paying for is the provenance of the item, not so much the thing itself. While I'm skeptical that the NFT form of "digitally assigned provenance" will be valued similarly, I can understand the argument for why a piece of digital artwork with an associated NFT isn't that different from a piece of physical art with the artist's signature.
- stickfigure 5y agoScarcity is necessary but not sufficient. What sets BTC apart from NTFs is its fungibility. In theory, there are an infinite number of potential cryptocurrencies, sure. But everyone has already embraced bitcoin (and a small handful of others), and replacing that userbase is an incredibly tall hurdle. On the other hand, minting a new beanie-baby-NFT takes less effort than making an actual beanie baby.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI think you're missing the purpose of NFTs. Again, I think the best analogy is really the art market. Most art in the art market is pretty worthless (at least monetarily) - just go to one of a bajillion garage sales to see why. But a few pieces of art will be worth a lot because something about them is desirable. It's the same with NFTs. There will be a bajillion "beanie-baby-NFTs" that will be close to worthless. And then there will be a few of the "Charlie Bit My Finger" variety that people actually have desire to uniquely "own".
- stickfigure 5y agoThe difference is that you can hang art on your wall and say "that's an original" when your other rich friends come to visit. "I control some arbitrary bits on an arbitrary blockchain" will never have the same cachet.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- danShumway 5y ago> And then there will be a few of the "Charlie Bit My Finger" variety that people actually have desire to uniquely "own". Not necessarily. The original creator that issued that "Charlie Bit My Finger" NFT could also create 1,000 more of them tomorrow. And all of those NFTs would be exactly as valid as the original, it wouldn't be equivalent to making a print of the Mona Lisa. It wouldn't be downstream of the original NFT, the original NFT is just a link to a publicly hosted asset. You're trusting the creator that they won't do that, but you have no real guarantee that they won't. That's doubly true when you start looking at corporate-backed NFTs like what the NBA is doing. They control the entire supply of the NFTs they issue, you have no way to guarantee that they won't re-issue all of their NFTs that you own.
- doublerebel 5y agoThis is no different than any current artist with a limited print run. The earliest prints are typically still the most valuable and the artist has incentive not to create additional runs of the same artwork.
- danShumway 5y ago> This is no different than any current artist with a limited print run Right. But also nobody acts like limited print runs are mathematically non-fungible. If the best argument for NFTs is that they're scarce in the exact same way that existing systems produce scarcity, and that this scarcity is enforced using the same systems we already have, that's not a good argument for the existence of NFTs. You might as well just do normal token issuance using existing technology.
- baby 5y agoThere is no “scarcity” notion in NFT, each is by design unique.
- miracle2k 5y agoThat is actually correct and very smart. I can mint an infinite number of ERC20 tokens on Ethereum, and I can create an infinite number of Bitcoin clones. Bitcoin is only scarce in terms of its social support base being different than other coins; the same is true for any NFT. They simply have a supply of 1.
- danShumway 5y ago> minting a new beanie-baby-NFT takes less effort than making an actual beanie baby. I'll add onto this that the core technology has no way of verifying which beanie baby NFT is "valid" outside of traditional centralized mechanisms like IP law and large validators. You can duplicate NFTs that point to the same beanie-baby-NFT link, are totally indistinguishable, that don't have any artwork that you own, and nobody can stop you outside of centralized mechanisms. As soon as you try to build a market on top of NFTs, you're right back inside the current system of ownership enforced by legal contracts and centralized validators. At least with Bitcoin, you don't have to tie your wallet to a Twitter verification system to figure out whether or not your funds are real or just a low-effort scam. People can disagree with whether Bitcoin has value (I think it's a bad system), but at least it doesn't completely fall apart as soon as you leave Coinbase. NFTs really don't work at all unless they're tied to centralized services, because anybody can make an NFT for anything, regardless of whether they have any real relationship to the asset they're issuing. Even official accounts that are validated: you can mint 5,000 NFTs of the same beanie baby, nobody can stop that from happening. Any scarcity in the system is only self-imposed by the actors within that system.
- vokep 5y agoIs this really a meaningful thing? I mean, of course it is somewhat in terms of how things are viewed. But, theres no religious law that NFTs must be a pure blockchain thing. Possibly they're finding their niche, and that is to be a sort of intermediate, which uses traditional systems as the origin of verification/trust, but can then go forward on its own with no further verification. (Of course, your wallet keys could be stolen and used to impersonate you, but the same is true for login credentials of twitter blue checkmarks)
- meheleventyone 5y agoSelling digital assets like that predates NFTs. NFTs are supposed to be special because of the stuff crypto adds not in spite of it.
- danShumway 5y agoWhat does the addition of a blockchain help with here? Selling? Not really, because the recommendation to avoid copycat NFTs is to sell/buy them through official platforms that will verify them. Display? NFTs do nothing to prevent link rot, and in fact make it harder to correct when it does happen. Coordination/portability between platforms? There's nothing that guarantees that platforms will respect each other's NFTs. > But, there's no religious law that NFTs must be a pure blockchain thing. Every time someone tells me that verification and enforcement are inherently social/legal processes and not processes that the blockchain is designed to solve, I feel like they're just one step away from finally understanding why people don't like NFTs. The only value of adding all of this math and environmental impact and complication and fragility to the system of buying digital assets is if doing so decreases the social/legal burden of verification. And NFTs don't do that, they don't do anything. They don't even make the secondary market safe. There are of course systems you could build on top of NFTs that would help solve some of these problems. But you could also build these systems without using NFTs. None of the proposals I've heard about enabling decentralized verification on the secondary market, or making it easier to pay artists, or building a web of trust for issuers -- none of those proposals need NFTs to exist before they can be built. The vast majority of these proposals don't require anything other than basic federation, and many don't even need that. The blockchain part isn't adding anything, it's useless. We could have the exact same conversation we're having right now, and come up with all of the same solutions for verifying and distributing digital assets without ever needing to talk about or consider a blockchain. It's not adding anything, it's just kind of there. And you're right, there's no strict law that everything must happen on the chain. So we could also just drop the chain entirely, use the same token issuance systems that have existed for ages, and focus only on solving the problems that actually need to be solved.
- hanklazard 5y agoLet’s look beyond the “art” NFTs for a moment and think about how else they can be used. NFTs, in addition to being collectibles, can be used to unlock access to features, like an exclusive chat room or give the holder access to bonus content only available to those X number of NFTs which were minted. Furthermore, secondary markets could easily exist for transferring access, something that is not really doable these days with accounts. I’m with you that the current art/collectible NFT craze seems a bit much, but I actually think the future utility of this “access” property is where things will get interesting.
- stickfigure 5y agoYou know what's actually useful - today - for compensating artists and unlocking access to features? Patreon. A glorified mailing list with a subscription fee. NFTs are inferior to that; at least the artist gets your email address.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- grey-area 5y agoUnlocking features - you’ve just reinvented a subscription plan. We have those and they work fine, why the blockchain? Secondary markets - why would vendors want or put up with that?! This is explicitly disallowed in most contracts for a reason. There is no utility here, the use value of nfts for tracking ownership and of bitcoin as a currency are both close to zero.
- analog31 5y agoIn my view there's a finite number of Picasso paintings, but an as yet unlimited possible number of digital artworks, and an unpredictable number of things that could compete with digital artworks for the dollars of buyers. To fix the supply of digital artworks, there has to be at least a loose consensus on what the accepted "canon" of those works consists of. For now, that's an unknown.
- tsimionescu 5y agoThere's a finite number of Picasso paintings, but an infinite number of non-digital artworks. Digital art is no different from physical art in terms of availability.
- analog31 5y agoTrue, all of the paintings in hotel rooms. In my view, the value of Picassos is partly due to a loosely accepted "canon" of paintings that are considered to be of particular value. If hotel paintings were discovered to be of equal artistic quality, it would not put them in the "canon." The supply is artificially limited by social convention. Art prices are also driven in part by a partial record of sales, so at least we know what some paintings sold for in the past. What we don't know about the digital art world is what conventions will emerge, that define the "supply" of works of particular value.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> It's kind of like saying there could be an infinite number of paintings, so why should Picassos be worth very much? We could mint an infinite number of Picasso NFTs, though. None of them are the actual piece of art. You could argue that one particular NFT is the official Picasso NFT because it was sold by the owners of the Picasso painting, but it’s still just a fancy hyperlink to a page that says “This is a Picasso NFT”. NFTs are basically fancy blockchain transactions with a memo field that can say “This represents a Picasso painting” and we’re all supposed to believe that it means something. The closest equivalent would be something like baseball cards. There is a market for baseball trading cards, but everyone is fully aware that they’re still just arbitrary prices of printed cardboard.
- willio58 5y agoJust minting something does not give it value. Sure, you can give it a price. Likely nobody will pay for it unless they think it truly has value. It’s the responsibility of each NFT creator to convince people that it’s worth anything.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bravetraveler 5y agoSubsequent 'owners' too. One could say having your name on the trail diminishes the value Just smells like laundering to me
- tsimionescu 5y agoWell, the art market is also largely powered by the elites' need to launder money, so in this sense they are similar.
- tshaddox 5y ago> You could argue that one particular NFT is the official Picasso NFT because it was sold by the owners of the Picasso painting I’m pretty sure the analogy would be that Picasso himself actually issued the NFT. Anyone can “argue” that Picasso issued an NFT, but that’s just like arguing that your extremely skillful forgery is a Picasso original. What’s important is if it actually is an original.
- chupchap 5y agoAnd what is stopping someone from creating multiple NFTs for the same art?
- dpweb 5y agoOrson Wells' F for Fake is a terrific film about an art forger, that explores concepts of art, authenticity, and value. In the film, an artist forges works of art by famous artists and fraudulently sells them to museums. It's implied that the museums don't know they are forgeries or don't care. So why is a Picasso more valuable than a perfect reproduction of it? I think the point is, it's all just perception, and greed. Cryptography is a highly significant technology, but cryptocurrency and now NFT too often just smacks of a money making scheme, promoted by self-serving people who happen to own a lot of it.