4 ms·
This assumes that the downsides of labor (monotony, debilitating or fatal injury (particularly in the case of much-touted "shovel-ready" projects)) don't count.
by cma 15y ago
This assumes that the downsides of labor (monotony, debilitating or fatal injury (particularly in the case of much-touted "shovel-ready" projects)) don't count. If the end product of the artificial jobs minus those downsides provides less individual and social utility than simply paying the worker a stipend, we should go with the stipend and forget the work.
- davidw 15y agoThere are probably some psychological benefits to doing something, even if it's only building trails in the forest or things like Timberline Lodge or various endeavors like that. Probably best to study it though, rather than simply conjecture.
- krschultz 15y agoYou are vastly over-estimating injuries on construction projects. They happen, but not like it was 1920 or 1850 or 2000 BC.
- cma 15y agoFair enough, but I'll assume (based on your omission) that you are vastly underestimating the downsides of monotony.
- lsc 15y agoI think that most people would prefer a job doing something they feel is useful. Heck, I'd take some moderate risks to feel like I was earning my keep. I think this is why most public assistance programs in America have been tied to 'service' of one kind or another. It's why social security is at least partly tied to your taxes while you were working. We've got our pride; and yeah, I agree it's irrational, but that's just the way many of us are. Actually, I got one of those hiring bonuses last year; I mean, I didn't know that I'd get it, and it was only a few hundred dollars, so it didn't factor in to the hiring decision, but I did make someone an actual employee, and my accountant told me I got a credit for it. (The guy was a contractor before, but he did get a substantial raise, and a steady salary rather than a varying paycheck based on hours worked.)