3 ms·
All you really need is materials shown to have melted at temperatures well beyond what could be achieved at the time, and a sharp peak of platinum-group metals.
by ncmncm 5y ago
All you really need is materials shown to have melted at temperatures well beyond what could be achieved at the time, and a sharp peak of platinum-group metals.
Then the burden is on the skeptics to explain how those got there by some other means.
If you think you got some shocked quartz, you might as well take pics. If it's not, really, that doesn't matter.
We have lots of both in coincident layers all over North America, South America, Africa, and at Abu Hureyra, demonstrating a strike coincident with the start of the Younger Dryas 1400-year freeze and 32+ genera of large American mammals suddenly gone extinct, including a cheetah, horses, camels, dire wolves, sabretooth cats, several pachyderms, a giant sloth, and a bear much bigger than the grizzly.
If we have a platinum metals peak there, and demonstrated melting of materials that need 2000+°C to melt, that is good enough for me. It is remarkably good aim to devastate two nearby sites only 10,000 years apart, but how surprising is it that disasters happened at places we were interested enough in to dig up? There could be plenty more strikes at places we don't dig up, and so haven't noticed.
The actual paper only mentions Sodom in passing. The news stories are what play it up. What bothers me some is that I have not heard of a meteor delivering a lot of NaCL anywhere else. Also there is not much detail on what is supposed to have happened at Jericho.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoMaybe I'm misunderstanding you, but what makes you expect the NaCL would be delivered by meteor? The area is geologically rich in salt already. From wiki: Movements of the Great Rift Valley system, along with the pressure generated by the slow accumulation of earth and rock, pressed down on the layers of salt, creating Mount Sodom. It is about 80% salt, 720 feet (220 m) high, capped by a layer of limestone [...] Because of weathering, some portions have separated. One of these pillars is known as "Lot's wife", in reference to the Biblical account of the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mount_Sodom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mount_Sodom
- ncmncm 5y agoI see. So, the salt might be from a tsunami or something splashed up from the Dead Sea.