3 ms·
> Anyone doing so should be disqualified from ever being a cop. Preferably by ending up in prison, among the general population.
by vkou 5y ago
> Anyone doing so should be disqualified from ever being a cop.
Preferably by ending up in prison, among the general population.
- gruez 5y agoGreat idea! Let's punish extra-judicial punishment with... extra-judicial punishment /s
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tombert 5y agoShould we not hold the people who are given a higher amount of power to a higher standard? I feel like the only way that it makes sense to have some sort of Leviathan-esque system is if we have assurances that the enforcers can be trusted.
- gruez 5y ago>Should we not hold the people who are given a higher amount of power to a higher standard? You don't need extra-judicial and/or cruel and unusual punishment to do that.
- tombert 5y agoHow is putting cops in prison extra-judicial or cruel and unusual? I do think cops should get harsher sentences for abusing their power because, again, they're given extra power. If we cannot trust the enforcers of the law, then I am skeptical of the concept of enforcers. But of course I think there should be a standard trial and whatnot, I'm not suggesting we go to Mad Max or anything like that. I'm not saying we summarily execute every cop who has run a red light, but I'm saying that if a cop does a bad thing, then it shouldn't be an outlier case for them to go to prison for it.
- gruez 5y ago>How is putting cops in prison extra-judicial or cruel and unusual? It's not, but GP's exact words were (emphasis mine): >Preferably by ending up in prison, among the general population. Which I've taken to imply "...so they'd get beaten up by fellow inmates". I'm not sure why he'd bring up that detail other than to imply that. As for the rest of the comment, I'm not disagreeing with you on those points.
- tombert 5y agoFair enough! I misread your intent. I would be against cops being abused by the inmates (just as I would any other prisoner), though I would be in favor of cops getting increased sentences for equivalent crimes.
- mdp2021 5y ago> Which I've taken to imply Unless you consider the interpretation "since they are part of the general population, they are picked from it, they are not outside the set of the "little people", they have a provisional mandate given under conditions, "equality" in modern societal systems means "all are the same in front of the law" and practical exceptions do not constitute substantial exceptions".
- sdenton4 5y agoSo, you're saying that putting cops in jail is cruel and unusual punishment... Probably means we shouldn't do that to anyone.
- sdenton4 5y agoOr, perhaps, judicial punishment. The official carve-outs for police misbehavior are unacceptable. And, unofficially, prosecutors are strongly disincentivized to prosecute cops: they're the DAs primary witnesses in many cases.
- gruez 5y ago>Or, perhaps, judicial punishment I don't think that's what the parent poster was advocating. see: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28713675 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28713675 >The official carve-outs for police misbehavior are unacceptable. And, unofficially, prosecutors are strongly disincentivized to prosecute cops: they're the DAs primary witnesses in many cases. Don't disagree with you on any of those.
- conductr 5y agoThe carve outs make sense on paper and maybe more so at the time they were written. But now the mountain of evidence displaying how humans can not be trusted with that type of power/responsibility is overwhelming.
- eyelidlessness 5y agoLet’s do prison reform too then.
- gruez 5y agoGreat, now you made the reform 2x harder to pass because now you'd need to get voters on board with prison reform. I'm not sure what the point of "let's give corrupt cops extra-judicial punishment by putting them in dangerous situations, but that's fine because we'll also simultaneously fix the dangerous situation!"
- eyelidlessness 5y ago1. Doesn’t have to be the same legislation or regulation effort. It’s okay to say “crime penalties shouldn’t be dangerous” as a response to “people who impose penalties on others should be subject to their own penalties” -> “those penalties are dangerous”. 2. Why should I care more about the extrajudicial punishment of cops more than the extrajudicial punishment of the people they abuse? 3. One of the best pieces of political advice I ever got was “demand the impossible”. Anything less is selling short whatever compromise you can achieve and reframing your next attempt. It doesn’t mean you stick to your demand, it just means you start from your principles and adjust from there.
- gruez 5y ago>1. Doesn’t have to be the same legislation or regulation effort. It’s okay to say “crime penalties shouldn’t be dangerous” as a response to “people who impose penalties on others should be subject to their own penalties” -> “those penalties are dangerous”. In other words, you're for extra-judicial punishment? >2. Why should I care more about the extrajudicial punishment of cops more than the extrajudicial punishment of the people they abuse? Because we as a society don't believe in "eye for an eye". >3. One of the best pieces of political advice I ever got was “demand the impossible”. Anything less is selling short whatever compromise you can achieve and reframing your next attempt. It doesn’t mean you stick to your demand, it just means you start from your principles and adjust from there. There's a limit to this, right? If you believe in a full communist revolution, "start from your principles" will get you absolutely nowhere, whereas advocating for some pro-social policies might actually do (eg. medicare expansion, free daycare).
- vkou 5y agoIf general population is good enough for normal people illegally committing violence, it should be good enough for the police illegally committing violence.