3 ms·
The new version > "Participants should speak and act with good intentions, but understand that intent and impact are not equivalent." Huh. That's interesting
by bawolff 5y ago
The new version
> "Participants should speak and act with good intentions, but understand that intent and impact are not equivalent."
Huh. That's interesting phrasing. I don't think i like it. Literally nobody thinks impact & intent are equivalent, the sticky point in human interaction and morality is to what extent do we take results instead of intentions into account when evaluating the morality of an action. The statement as is isn't saying anything about how we should interpret intent vs result just that we should acknowledge that its different.
I personally believe that codes of conduct (both this current trend, but also in the traditional meaning of the word) should be specific about what behaviour is wanted, otherwise its a meaningless platitude. This says nothing about how we should interpret someone doing something hurtful while not intending to (or claiming not to). Is that ok? Is it only ok if a "reasonable" person would make the same mistake? Is it ok if they haven't made the same mistake before? Something else?
- oh_sigh 5y agoIt's just laying out exactly what you seem to agree with, and that good intentions aren't a shield for bad results. Someone might say "you look really sexy today" and intend it as a compliment, but even if it is a compliment it almost certainly isn't going to be received as one.
- bawolff 5y agoIs it laying that out? I think you have to significantly read between the lines to get there. > what you seem to agree with, that good intentions aren't a shield for bad results I wasn't giving my opinion so much as sumarizing its an unsolved problem with no obvious correct answer. If you want my personal view. I don't believe actual results should be taken into account at all. "you look really sexy today" isn't wrong to say because the recipent was offended. It's wrong to say because a reasonably acculturized person would know that there is a high chance it would be offensive in context. If the dice were on your side, and for some reason the recipent was delighted at your "compliment", i would still say it was wrong because you had no way of knowing that that would be the outcome. The wrongness has nothing to do with what actually happened, only with what was reasonably predictable to happen. There are pros and cons to this view, and reasonable people do disagree. [And to be clear, even if something was not predictable and therefore not "wrong", that doesn't absolve you from having to apologize/make it right if you accidentally hurt someone]
- hanselot 5y ago"Now now Sally, everyone knows before we can talk to another human, unless you are a protected class, you have to sign an interaction receival request. Don't be scared honey, only about half of all interaction receival requests are deemed offensive by the receiver, and punishable by removal of the tongue. Besides, how do you expect daddy to get another loaf of bread if I don't request one from our local CoC Kommando? I need you to be brave in this world, as right now you are a protected class, you can bargain on my behalf. Please go to the entity presiding over that area and beg them/their/it/they to be sparing with the interaction receival request litigation fees."
- oh_sigh 5y ago> It's wrong to say because a reasonably acculturized person would know that there is a high chance it would be offensive in context. And what if you're not a "reasonably acculturized" person?
- bawolff 5y agoThat's the rub, right. If reasonable behaviour and common sense was obvious, there would be no need for CoC or even laws. Ultimately it devolves into what a majority of the group understands the norms of the group to be. The implicit assumption is that all members of the group have an implicit duty to understand the shared norms of the group (sort of like in the legal sphere where ignorance of the law is not a defense, but unintentionally breaking the law is, provided that the lack of intentionality isn't soley based on ignorance of what the laws are). E.g. in the case you mentioned earlier, sexualizing co-workers is the wrong thing. Not knowing that sexualizing coworkers is not a defense. If you say something with a double meaning, which you ernestly didn't realize had a double meaning, that might be a defense. You didn't intend to break a rule, and your unintentional rule breakage had nothing to do with not knowing what the rules are. It doesn't mean you don't have to apologize, but it should be enough [on this view] to prevent punitive action (generally, as always context matters). You could say that feels unsatisfactory, and you're right it does - its squishy and subjective. I don't hold this view because i think its perfect, but just because i think its the least bad of the alternatives.
- odshoifsdhfs 5y agoWhat about "That shirt looks really good on you"? Is it a compliment or the receiver may think you just want to rip it off them and have sex on the desk right there and then??
- MadeThisToReply 5y ago> Literally nobody thinks impact & intent are equivalent You haven't been paying attention - the (preposterous) idea that "intent doesn't matter, only impact" is a key premise of modern social justice activism and is taught to undergraduates as unquestionable fact.
- wccrawford 5y agoWhat amazes me is that the CoC doesn't actually say that. It just says they're different. It relies on the reader to have already known that "intent doesn't matter, only impact" and anyone could actually interpret it as the opposite, especially if their culture already thinks that intent is the more important thing.
- jeltz 5y agoYeah, the legal tradition and mostly the morals of my country is based on intent is the only thing which matters. So a reasonable assumption for me would be that is a reminder that impact does not matter. I doubt that is what they mean but it is very far from clear, especially in an international context. Many of these CoCs are virtually impossible to understand unless you have at least a cursory understanding with contemporary American politics. Very inclusive ...
- hamilyon2 5y agoIs naiive consequentialism to the spirit of "oucome justifies means" really that popular? I ask because the law, legal system and even democratic values as we know them are built on very different principles. We definitely punish theft, burglary and fraud even if outcome giving to poor is seen as preferrable. We dont punish legal tax shenanigans and some shady philanthropy, even if outcome is poor. And when democratic majority is in favor of some stupid and harmful policy, we campaign against it, but still obey democratic majority.
- banannaise 5y agoThat's a highly disingenuous framing. A better framing would be "intent is not a sufficient excuse for impact". Intent is not meaningless, but unintentional harms need to be remedied by understanding the harm and working to change the behavior. If someone commits an unintentional harm repeatedly, it ceases to become unintentional, because the refusal to learn is deliberate.