3 ms·
How about 10,000 X-Prizes, each with a 10M or so prize. That seems much more sensible. Everyone who wanted to compete for a given prize could register with a tr
by Alex3917 15y ago
How about 10,000 X-Prizes, each with a 10M or so prize. That seems much more sensible. Everyone who wanted to compete for a given prize could register with a transparent prediction market, which would give investors an easy way to get to know the different people competing in each category.
- robryan 15y agoI like this idea, I think pushing the boundaries of tech can create more opportunities in the long run past just the prizes aspect. I think the key to the prizes is also that they should be in areas that could realistically be economically viable going forward.
- beambot 15y agoI really like this idea. It's sort of like a decentralized and transparent DARPA, only it can extend beyond defense. The contests could be a mix between incremental efficiency improvements as well as "pie in the sky" ideas. If coupled with a strong mentoring program per contestant, you could also target STEM education.
- nl 15y agoHow does that fix employment? It might be a highly efficient way of developing new technology, but prizes don't immediately generate large amounts of new employment. Think about it: most X-Prize-type competitions rely on the intelligence of a few highly skilled people, and even then only a few of them will actually win. The other teams generally make a loss, and so have to rely on "investors" to pay the bills. To fix employment you need to employ 10,000 ex-auto workers, who at best have some machinist skills if you are lucky. Then you need to do it ten more times. Then ten more. Then you need to do the same for the construction industry, for hospitality and for agricultural workers[1][2]. What's more, you need to do this fast - in months, not years. I cannot imagine anyway to structure a X-Prize to do that. [1] See the unemployment rates by sector: http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t14.htm http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t14.htm [2] To be fair, the hospitality industry will probably pick itself up once employment improves in other sectors so you might only need to generate a few 100K jobs instead of a million.
- tomjen3 15y agoIf they only get some machinist skills at best, then they are effectively unemployable. So rather than getting a job, they should start taking classes at the local community college. Then, once they have become nurses, care-takers, welders, electricians, etc, etc they won't have such a big problem finding jobs.
- nl 15y agoSeriously??! Nurses, care-takers: Unemployment rate = 5.9%, with 1.2 million (already trained) people unemployed Welders, electricians: That would be either the construction sector (Unemployment rate 13.6%) or the manufacturing sector (Unemployment rate 9.2%). Re-training will help some people, but isn't immediate and will never help the majority. There seems to be a weird view that manufacturing in the US will be dead in the future because it is struggling now. It's probably worth noting that rich, first world countries like Germany have huge manufacturing sectors, employing large number of people, and yet have to compete directly with countries with low wages. It isn't clear at all why some people believe the US is fated to lose its manufacturing sector but Germany isn't.
- tomjen3 15y agoThe US isn't going to loose its manufacturing sector anymore than Germany. It is just that there will be a lot less jobs in the future.