7 ms·
Blue Origin has a toxic culture, former and current employees say
- prepend 5y agoThe examples here don’t seem to indicate that a 3,600 person company has a toxic culture. It’s a dozen or so complaints and it seems weird to extrapolate that to the entire org without more data. Of course the headline is true that some employees think it’s toxic. But that’s not terribly remarkable without further info.
- bell-cot 5y agoFrom the article: "After publication of the essay, Ars spoke with several current and former employees who have provided reliable information in the past about the company. Although it is clear the essay was a product of disgruntled workers, these sources agreed that there were elements of truth in the essay. For these sources, the withering criticism of Blue Origin founder Jeff Bezos, and his hand-picked chief executive, Bob Smith, rang especially true." ...which speaks far more to Ars upholding journalistic standards than to the essay containing a high % of quality data. (Still, comparing Blue Origin's achievements with those of younger, likely far-less-well capitalized SpaceX...there sure seems to something badly wrong with Blue Origin.)
- prepend 5y ago> that there were elements of truth in the essay. This doesn’t sound damning at all and doesn’t seem to support the letter’s claim of toxic culture.
- rkochman 5y ago“The other signatories, a majority of whom were engineers, declined to publicly disclose their names because they did not want to jeopardize employment at Blue Origin or harm their prospects in the aerospace industry for other jobs.” That’s not how signing works.
- prepend 5y agoMy organization had an “open letter” published that claimed hundreds of signatories but wouldn’t disclose the signatures due to fear of reprisal. I’m not sure how effective this can be as the whole point of names signed is that they are real. A claim of signatures is not very useful. Cynically, every time I see a “secret list of signers” I just figure the number is zero or a bazillion as it doesn’t matter. It’s like Nixon’s “silent majority” of supporters.
- kelnos 5y agoI get what you are saying, but then what is the solution for people who have legitimate complaints, but fear reprisal if they don't remain anonymous? Not everyone has the luxury of being able to go up against their employer without repercussions that are worse than the original complaint. But that doesn't mean people should just have to suck it up and put up with unjust (and perhaps illegal) behavior.
- angelzen 5y ago"This org is kind of shitty. Sadly, I need to move on.". That's what the vast majority of people do. Unless there are clearly illegal acts, say withholding pay or physical endangerment, not sure why people would want to pick a public fight with their employer. It's a lose-lose proposition.
- prepend 5y agoI think the solution is to not make unverifiable claims. Just write a letter and have it stand on its merits. If I can’t disclose the identity of 21 people and have no way of verifying that 21 people did someone, I can just not mention that part.
- bumby 5y ago"Fear of reprisal" is one of the primary measures of a toxic culture. But I get what you're saying about it almost being an unfalsifiable claim.
- philwelch 5y ago
- pinewurst 5y agoIt's interesting that BO tries to tar the author by claiming she was terminated for violations of federal export control regulations - but she was an employee communications manager. How does such a role even intersect with that? Reading the original essay (https://www.lioness.co/post/bezos-wants-to-create-a-better-future-in-space-his-company-blue-origin-is-stuck-in-a-toxic-past https://www.lioness.co/post/bezos-wants-to-create-a-better-f...) - it's a strange mix of odious sexual harassment and the seemingly trivial (pissed because the building isn't LEED).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- la6471 5y agoWhy is someone pushing TFA again and again in HN?
- rbanffy 5y agoHN'ers think Blue Origin is an interesting topic, I guess. So far, it's a clear failure, but in this business everyone is a couple bad decisions away from failure anyway.
- lr1970 5y ago> It's interesting that BO tries to tar the author by claiming she was terminated for violations of federal export control regulations - but she was an employee communications manager. How does such a role even intersect with that? Surprisingly, export control regulations come in play when hiring (on H1B visa) nationals from some lucky countries like Cuba, North Korea, Iran. It is HR responsibility to comply in each and every case.
- downrightmike 5y agoLittle dick energy filters down.
- mastrsushi 5y agoBillionaire intellectuals that privately fund space programs are surprisingly unethical.
- jjtheblunt 5y agoIs this correlated with months-ago leaks about toxic culture in Amazon?
- pinewurst 5y agoNo - people have been talking about toxic Amazon culture for at least the past decade. It should be little surprise that Bezos' other enterprise is not a fun place.
- cratermoon 5y agoBlue Origin has a toxic culture. Amazon has a toxic culture. What do they have in common?
- teakettle42 5y agoThey’re convenient targets for a new breed of muckraking so-called journalists?
- kcplate 5y agoI’ll take “Large companies founded by a billionaire public figure” for a $1000, Alex.
- WalterBright 5y agoThe Apollo program was greatly accelerated to meet Kennedy's 10 year goal and the worry that the Russians would get their first. A lot of intermediate testing was skipped. Fortunately, things went well with Apollo 11. It's telling that Bezos felt confident enough to personally ride in the inaugural manned launch.
- bumby 5y agoIs there any evidence that testing was skipped? It seems to me, testing may likely be more robust now simply because we've learned more and have a greater understanding of failure modes, rather than previous a deliberate skimping of testing during Apollo
- WalterBright 5y agoI've read a couple of books on how several Apollo test missions were skipped and they went straight to the landing shot. They were skipped in order to meet the time goals, and made a lot of people nervous. One system they had big problems with were the Saturn V engines, which had a tendency to violently pogo (dynamic instability). The Russian moon program had the same problem, and they gave up on it.
- spoonjim 5y agoIs there a company that has achieved world transforming impact without at least some employees calling it “toxic”?
- AtlasBarfed 5y agowell, low world orbit transforming impact.
- spoonjim 5y agoOh, not implying that BO is there yet. But Tesla, SpaceX, Apple, Amazon, clearly are and have all been called toxic. Hell, even Microsoft was once extremely toxic, especially if you were in a room with Bill Gates.
- tailrecursion 5y agoI agree, I think this is a penetrating and fair question to ask. Some may feel it's dismissive of the complaints. But 95% or more of the complaints in the letter are characterizations, not descriptions. Take for example the HR executive groping another employee. What does groping mean? Brushing? Back of the hand? Possibly accidental? Grabbing? Pinching? This is a pattern with activists, using characterizations. And the executive was fired after the groping incident, which means...the system works? He was fired in spite of being a high-level exec, in spite of his personal ties to Bezos. Another example concerns a female manager I believe who was fired abruptly. This is presented as an example of a bias in favor of men. So... no man's ever been fired abruptly? No man's ever been escorted out of the building by security? It's not allowed to fire women abruptly? Yet another example in the letter is a man saying to a group of women something like "you need to listen to me because I'm a man". But... isn't that what feminism is? Don't feminists go to groups of men and say "You have to listen to me for no other reason than I'm a woman". It's difficult for me to see how any thinking person can read that letter and not see it as an example of fainting feminism. [Edited, spelling, sarcasm removed]
- tonmoy 5y agoI a woman complains about groping at a workplace and it is anything but accidental, it doesn't matter what "kind" of groping it is! It creates a hostile environment in the workplace. Sure, in this incident after the complain the person was fired. What about the hundreds of times he had done something like this and the woman because of comments like yours had NOT filed a complaint? For your listen to me argument just "NO". It doesn't matter what your straw man feminist says, at a workplace it is NOT ok to say "you need to listen to me because I'm a man". It is also not ok to say "you need to listen to me because I'm a woman"
- ajhurliman 5y agoWait, she was fired 2 years ago and she's _still_ railing against Blue Origin? It doesn't seem healthy to hold onto hatred for that long.
- codezero 5y agoYou must never have been fired from a draining and toxic role that without the toxic part, you loved and wanted to make a career of only to get shit on and then fired and then threatened and shit on some more. Lucky. It easily took me two years to stop letting scar tissue and impostor syndrome from affecting my professional and personal life, and I was very aware of it and working on it.
- mithusingh32 5y agoThese stories are true for any major defense contractor. Working at a large defense contract is always a coin flip. I know people who have loved it from day 1 ( aka people who have been there 15+ years) or have left after a year or two. It seems defense contractors do not care for new hires. They will always give senior staff favor and not push younger staff to become better.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoGlass Door for rocket companies: Relativity Space, Tim Ellis: 95% approve SpaceX, Elon Musk: 92% approve Rocket Lab, Peter Beck: 81% approve ULA, Tory Bruno: 77% approve Boeing, David Calhoun: 71% approve Blue Origin, Bob Smith: 18% approve https://twitter.com/SciGuySpace/status/1418971851066429447 https://twitter.com/SciGuySpace/status/1418971851066429447
- sprafa 5y agoWow that’s the biggest piece of evidence that the letter is accurate. 18% is abysmal