3 ms·
'Exhaustive'? They may have been exhausting (!) but can you really ever search exhaustively for a species?
by OJFord 5y ago
'Exhaustive'? They may have been exhausting (!) but can you really ever search exhaustively for a species?
- mumblemumble 5y agoAt the very very least, "exhaustive" and "exhausting" are potential synonyms. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/exhaustive#Adjective https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/exhaustive#Adjective I'd argue that definition 2 is also a decent fit, and definition 1 is acceptable if you permit mild hyperbole. (Which I'd advise doing, as mild hyperbole is more-or-less the default register of Standard American English.)
- OJFord 5y ago> mild hyperbole is more-or-less the default register of Standard American English Well as a speaker of British English, I suppose that's where I fell down. They're very much not synonyms as far as I'm concerned, my 'exhausting' was a joke, being 'very tiring, causing exhaustion' vs. the 'every possible element, comprehensive' from your Wiktionary link for 'exhaustive'. You can't possibly check everywhere. I don't say that out of some sort of extinction denial! I assume there are standards in the field for time since sighting over certain number of known habitats or percentage coverage of land or whatever that indicates extinction. I just wouldn't call that 'after exhaustive search', personally. 'Extensive', sure. 'Sufficient to meet criteria for extinction' is what matters.
- mumblemumble 5y agoIt seems believable? I definitely don't intend to accuse you of extinction denialism. But I would believe it's one of those subtle differences between American English and other dialects. I frequently get the impression that, when it comes to range of expression, my native dialect is a bit like music mastering in the CD era: no medium intensity anymore; instead everything's pushed up against - and being clipped by - the upper limit of the dynamic range. This is a dialect where "awesome" doesn't mean anything remotely like "awe-inspiring", except in books that were written prior to the late 20th century.
- murphyslab 5y agoTens of thousands of naturalists (e.g. birders) have been looking for evidence for decades. It's a pretty wide net, particularly with citizen science platforms such as iNaturalist and eBird. As for whether it's possible, I would say yes. Environmental DNA (eDNA) sampling can be used to see if a particular species is present even if you don't visually or audibly observe the species: > eDNA is increasingly being used for biosurveillance, species occupancy studies, and the detection of endangered and invasive species, particularly in aquatic ecosystems [0] There's a very recent paper that has demonstrated that animal DNA can be obtained from the air and used to identify animals present in a given space. [0] > Clare set up vacuum pumps with filters in 20 locations in Hamerton Zoo Park and let each run for 30 minutes. [...] The team identified 17 species kept at the zoo and others living near and around it, such as hedgehogs and deer. Some zoo animal DNA was found nearly 300 meters from the animals' enclosures. She also detected airborne DNA likely from the meat of chicken, pig, cow, and horse fed to captive predators indoors. [1] In the near future we'll probably see fairly widespread use of this kind of tech in the search for rare and evasive species. [0] : https://peerj.com/articles/11030/ https://peerj.com/articles/11030/ [1] : https://www.science.org/news/2021/07/dna-pulled-thin-air-identifies-nearby-animals https://www.science.org/news/2021/07/dna-pulled-thin-air-ide...
- OJFord 5y agoUndeniably extensive. I don't deny it as sufficient evidence to claim extinction. I just don't think it can (or could ever) be called 'exhaustive'.