13 ms·
This round got a lot further than the last round. I went through Stanford CS in the mid 1980s, just as it was becoming clear that expert systems didn't really
by Animats 5y ago
This round got a lot further than the last round.
I went through Stanford CS in the mid 1980s, just as it was becoming clear that expert systems didn't really do much. There had been Stanford faculty running around claiming "strong AI real soon now" to Congress. Big-time denial as the field collapsed. Almost all the 1980s AI startups went bust. The "AI winter" followed. Today, expert systems are almost forgotten.
This time around, there are large, successful industries using machine learning. Tens of thousands of people understand it. It's still not "strong AI", but it's useful and profitable. So work will continue.
We're still at least one big idea short of "strong AI". A place to look for it is in "common sense", narrowly defined as "not doing something really bad in the next 30 seconds". This just requires lower mammal level AI, not human level. Something with the motion planning and survival capabilities of a squirrel, for example, would be a big advance.
(I once had a conversation with Rod Brooks about this. He'd been building six-legged robot insects, and was giving a talk about how his group was making the jump to human level AI, with a project called "Cog". I asked why such a big jump? Why not try for a robot mouse, which might be within reach. He said "I don't want to go down in history as the man who created the world's best robot mouse". Cog was a flop, and Brooks goes down in history as the the creator of the robot vacuum cleaner.)
- dreamcompiler 5y ago> There had been Stanford faculty running around claiming "strong AI real soon now" to Congress. That would be Ed Feigenbaum, the man who (IMHO) almost single-handedly brought on the AI winter of the 80s. Because of him we had to call all the AI research we did in the 90s something other than "AI" lest it get shut down instantly.
- Animats 5y agoUm, yes. His book. "The Fifth Generation - Artificial Intelligence and Japan's Computer Challenge to the World" lays out his position. For a short version, here's his testimony before a congressional committee, asking for funding.[1] "The era of reasoning machines is inevitable. It is the "manifest destiny" of computing." He was taken seriously at the time. Chief Scientist of the USAF at one point. Turing Award. [1] https://stacks.stanford.edu/file/druid:mv321kw4621/mv321kw4621.pdf https://stacks.stanford.edu/file/druid:mv321kw4621/mv321kw46...
- listenallyall 5y ago> The era of reasoning machines is inevitable. It is the "manifest destiny" of computing." Isn't this pretty much the current opinion of the majority of the thousands of AI researchers and programmers today? Maybe this guy was early to the party but his vision seems in alignment with today's practitioners.
- dreamcompiler 5y agoYes; if anything the hype is even stronger today. The difference is that neural nets on modern hardware really do quite a few useful things, while expert systems on 80s hardware mostly did not. The reason the hype of today is more dangerous is what I call the grandmother issue: In the 80s we dreamed of a program that would recognize your grandmother when she walked in the room. That was one of our holy grails. Good news: The grandmother recognizer was finally built with deep neural nets in the 2000s and it works pretty well. It's not perfect but if you tell it to play grandma's favorite song when she walks in the room it's no big deal if it occasionally fails to recognize her, or if it plays the song when someone other than your grandma walks in the room. Bad news: We now have people who (effectively) want to attach the grandmother recognizer to a machine gun with instructions to shoot your grandmother and only your grandmother, and never to fail to shoot her if she walks in the room. Suddenly the Type 1 and Type 2 errors are a whole lot more consequential. Modern NNs are simply not fit for that job. We have pretty good AI for low-consequence purposes, but it cannot be used for high-consequence purposes without a lot more fundamental research. Incremental improvements to deep learning are not going to get us there.
- giardini 5y agoWellllll, um, not really.... Any NN recognizer can be fooled and your neighbor's dog may as likely be shot by the "granny gun AI". You need to read up on the validity of facial recognition software. It ain't nearly human!
- zcw100 5y ago"not human level. Something with the motion planning and survival capabilities of a squirrel" I think you're underestimating how smart a squirrel is.
- quantified 5y agoOk robot, solve this: [https://youtu.be/hFZFjoX2cGg https://youtu.be/hFZFjoX2cGg] (John Rober’s squirrel maze, one of the most wonderful concotions I’ve found on Youtube.)
- Animats 5y agoIt's an indication that we're missing something. A squirrel has somewhere around 75 million to 100 million neurons. That's not all that many in terms of modern hardware. We ought to be able to build squirrel-level AI with cellphone-sized hardware. What are we missing?
- rsj_hn 5y agoThere is a big jump from "let's create some algorithms and data structures inspired by a simple model of the brain and see what kind of problems these algorithms are useful for" to "why doesn't our model fully and faithfully represent an actual brain". The first of these questions has led to real progress in things like image recognition, whereas the second of these questions has not led any real progress in digitizing squirrel brains.
- Animats 5y agoOpenWorm is, after years of work, up to nematode level.[1] Their WormSim is an emulation, at the neuron level, of the simplest creature whose nervous system has been fully mapped. 302 neurons, 25 muscle cells. Runs in a browser. So true bottom-up is not hopeless. [1] https://openworm.org/ https://openworm.org/
- giardini 5y agoAnimats says "Cog was a flop, and Brooks goes down in history as the the creator of the robot vacuum cleaner." Would that be the "robot vacuum cleaner that can't see shite?": https://www.boredpanda.com/robot-vacuum-cleaner-spreads-dog-shit-everywhere/?utm_source=duckduckgo&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=organic https://www.boredpanda.com/robot-vacuum-cleaner-spreads-dog-...
- camkego 5y agoIf you get the upgrade, it can see the poo. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28475716 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28475716