6 ms·
But there's tons of room in the market for stuff that fails spectacularly 2% of the time. That's the key insight. It's why the commercial successes of AI have
by Animats 5y ago
But there's tons of room in the market for stuff that fails spectacularly 2% of the time.
That's the key insight. It's why the commercial successes of AI have been primarily in advertising, marketing, and investing.
- ssivark 5y agoThat’s an interesting insight. What are the long term societal implications of enabling/inducing (Jevons paradox) activities which are not “important enough” to need 100% correctness?
- Jensson 5y ago> commercial successes of AI have been primarily in advertising, marketing, and investing. Which is why people say that it has few useful applications. People don't care if those areas become more effective. Another important application is mass surveillance, which people would also argue isn't a good thing.
- worik 5y agoInvesting? Is there any evidence that any AI is better than index buy and hold? I do not think there is.
- tomComb 5y agoThe only thing consistently better than that is insider info, which is very common and quite reliable.
- NumberCruncher 5y agoThere was a saying before 2008: "How do you start an AI based FOREX trading fund? You pretend to be the russian prodigy developing the algo, while I do the insider trading".
- credit_guy 5y agoCan I propose another insight? AI sometimes works and works spectacularly and does not fail in 2% of the cases, or even in 0.02%. Just look at iPhone photos. But that AI application require deep domain knowledge + deep AI (or, well, ML, whatever) knowledge. You can't simply throw sklearn at an arbitrary problem and expect to get great results.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoIPhone photos do some weird shit a small portion of the time too. I've had mostly great experiences as well as the rare unrealistically colored outcomes or misplaced bokeh.
- whimsicalism 5y agoand translation, inference on text, inference on images, speech recognition, etc. there's plenty of bullshit uses of AI out there, but i think it is silly to say there are only limited commercial successes.
- machiaweliczny 5y agoYeah, also MoE models like Wu Dao 2.0 that if combined with work at FB with hypothesis generation (causality testing) and Codex can give some interesing applications like autowriting programs to specification. There were also some progress with geometric deep learining which kinda unifies architectures AFAIK. Disclaimer: not an expert
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoAmen. Translation's such a great example. I got some ingredients at a local market recently and used the google image translate function on it. I'm sure the translation was way off, and parts were entirely nonsensical, but it was enough for me to infer what the directions were. Tons of value in imperfect translation.
- otabdeveloper4 5y ago"AI" is not used at all in ad tech. (This is actually a problem when hiring people today. Nobody can do machine learning without some stupid big neural net framework.)
- Jensson 5y agoIt is, but it isn't as widespread as some thinks it is. Old school techniques like decision trees perform better for almost every ad tech tasks and are much cheaper, so if you can't do those you are basically worthless in the field. But sometimes a neural network is actually useful.