3 ms·
Identifying a best practice is actually not as hard as people realize imo (although it may take some time), and only becomes hard when you let emotion and sourc
by asdff 5y ago
Identifying a best practice is actually not as hard as people realize imo (although it may take some time), and only becomes hard when you let emotion and sources of emotion come into what should be a rational decision making process (such as preference for a certain tooling for reasons like familiarity or popularity in the field today rather than outright advantages vs other tooling).
To identify the best practice for anything, you start by doing a review of all the available practices in the field for a given problem you are working on. Then once you've reviewed the literature you can work out the pros, cons, caveats of each of these tools, and how these considerations affect your particular use case and your expected results. Then after doing that, the best practice out of available options will be readily apparent, or at the very least strongly justified, not by an appeal to authority or popularity or familiarity, but by looking at what the underlying technology actually does and how its relevant or not to your particular task at hand. In the end you will find the very best hammer available out of all the hammers people have made in this field for your particular unique nail.
- lucumo 5y agoThat sounds like a beautiful example of letting perfect be the enemy of good. Just like your design choices have trade-offs, is it important to realize that there's a trade-off between finishing sooner and making a better solution. Diminishing returns are usually very much in play with analysis. (I would also challenge the notion that every situation has a different "best practice". That's just creating a solution. "Best practices" are usually general advise that is applicable in most situations.)
- asdff 5y agoYou shouldn't take forever, but what I'm saying is a best practice emerges after doing however much due diligence. Maybe you spend an hour looking into it and that's it, but you should do your due diligence to vet what sort of approaches you can take to solve your particular problem as best you can, so you can make the best decision based on the evidence you've been able to find within however much time you are working with. A professor gave me a word of advice once, "a week in a library can save a month in the lab."
- lucumo 5y agoMost decisions don't require that much thought. They're low stakes and can easily be changed. To build on the professor's metaphor: don't spend a week in the library in it'll only save you a day. If it's a bit more important, do a quick Google, but only break out Excel for the comparison tables if the decision is life-changing. Honestly, the most important thing that professors don't teach and real life does is that sometimes the optimal thing to do is to not do the optimal thing.
- mbrodersen 5y agoTwo different “experts” will do this and arrive at different conclusions. Now what.