4 ms·
Why has society gotten so authoritarian lately? Arbitrary things shouldn't just be banned in free countries.
by josephcsible 5y ago
Why has society gotten so authoritarian lately? Arbitrary things shouldn't just be banned in free countries.
- ars 5y agoHe should have specified GAS leaf blowers - they are very polluting. But it doesn't have to be that way.
- ironmagma 5y agoYeah. Electric leaf blowers have existed for decades and coincidentally don’t have wasteful two stroke engines that largely serve as gasoline atomizers.
- ironmagma 5y agoTragedy of the commons. The expectation of freedom was that people will, in their pursuit of happiness, look out for their fellow citizen by being free in the most socially beneficial way feasible. Unfortunately because we aren’t a high-trust society anymore, that expectation is broken. With this basic level of responsibility violated, so too will evaporate the freedom.
- dTal 5y agoThere have been a number of high-profile demonstrations lately that people cannot be trusted. Why shouldn't we ban something, if its harm can be rigorously shown and yet people persist in using it? What does this lofty commitment to "freedom" actually buy?
- throwawaylinux 5y ago> There have been a number of high-profile demonstrations lately that people cannot be trusted. People in the government, or somewhere else? Trusted to do what you want them to, or? > Why shouldn't we ban something, if its harm can be rigorously shown and yet people persist in using it? Automobiles fit that bill. The problem is that the (well meaning) authoritarians believe that their equation for the cost and value of everything is the one true gold standard that society must set its clock and run by. > What does this lofty commitment to "freedom" actually buy? Lots of things. For you specifically, the freedom to isolate yourself at home, the freedom to wear a mask in public, and the freedom to decide to get vaccinated and make other decisions about your personal medical treatments. You didn't think without freedom that you'll still get to do what you want and the only change is that others will also be made to do what you want, right?
- ars 5y ago> There have been a number of high-profile demonstrations lately that people cannot be trusted. Presumably including you? > Why shouldn't we ban something Because the people doing the banning can't be trusted. > if its harm can be rigorously shown and yet people persist in using it That's a contradiction - if the harm is so obvious, people wouldn't do it. If they do do it, then clearly they don't agree with you that there is harm. Which means, don't ban it, since your POV is not superior to theirs.
- ironmagma 5y ago> if the harm is so obvious, people wouldn't do it. That's quite an assumption. I assume you've not met many cigarette smokers?
- ars 5y agoI have, and they believe the tradeoff (health for enjoyment) is worth it to them. I think they are idiots, but they don't. And my opinion is not superior to theirs.
- bradknowles 5y agoYour right to smoke a cigarette ends where it becomes second hand smoke that would enter my lungs.
- kalleboo 5y agoI used to think the same thing, that we're moving to people wanting to regulate evrything. But after watching/reading about a bunch of modern history, looking at the past century it's always been like this, it's just a combination of decades of regulation compounding as well as old regulation being taken for granted.