2 ms·
Thank you for two specific mentions. I can't find any "dirt" on them off the bat, so I'll try to find where I've read about pre-European contact Native American
by TeMPOraL 5y ago
Thank you for two specific mentions. I can't find any "dirt" on them off the bat, so I'll try to find where I've read about pre-European contact Native American tribes being not as sustainable as it's commonly held.
Incidentally, I've just found a 2020 paper claiming they did not have a noticeable impact on ecology before European arrived[0].
I currently have two competing hypothesis if it turns out I was wrong, and the various tribes did in fact lived sustainably. The first one is, they understood nature enough to live in a balanced way on purpose. The second one is, they just weren't large enough as a group to meaningfully upset the ecosystem around them.
I find the second slightly more likely given the information I have. But even if the first hypothesis is correct, there's still the question: would we like living like they lived? Are the lessons we could apply to lead sustainable lifestyles without abandoning the progress of science, and all the health improvements it brought?
> You don’t actually need the science to live in a way to see things in wholes, but the science can help.
I kind of disagree. Without the science, any kind of "seeing things in wholes" is limited to very small, local wholes, and/or lucky guesses.
--
[0] - https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/01/200122123700.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/01/200122123700.h...
- ahevia 5y ago> Are the lessons we could apply to lead sustainable lifestyles without abandoning the progress of science, and all the health improvements it brought? I have met very few people who try to live sustainable lifestyles but actively deny science. I agree that science can help inform and enhance how we live sustainably, but the way this question is posed makes it seem that those who live sustainably also deny reality. (I dont doubt they exist, I know a few, but they are the minority of folks who live this way).
- TeMPOraL 5y agoI meant something else: I meant, could we take the sustainability lessons of the Native Tribes in such a way that we both live sustainably and keep furthering science? I.e. it's not about denying reality - it's about continuing to learn more about it, and to apply it. In the past centuries, most important of scientific discoveries required having an industrial civilization. So implied in my question is, can we keep the progress of technology going (at least the non-abusive parts of it), because it's a flip side of scientific progress - they feed on themselves, and you can't have one without the other.
- ahevia 5y agoYeah I don’t see why not. I’ve collaborated with a handful of scientists of indigenous backgrounds who still practice their culture. That’s never even been a contradiction in their head. Living a sustainable life doesn’t impact or hinder science whatsoever.
- hosh 5y agoScience is useful and has its own epistomology ... but it is also not the only epistomology. It's commonly assumed that science is capable of learning anything and everything, but I think science, while useful in many context, is itself limited. Maybe someone will surprise me, but there are matters of consciousness, sentience, sapience, awareness that I have doubts the scientific method will ever come to understand. For me, exclusively using science to understand everything is as foolish as completely denying science ... but I also get that each person are navigating through life in their own way.