5 ms·
Sure it worked at reducing hate speech on reddit, but is that the right objective? It's not implausible to think that the resentment from such local measures co
by naasking 5y ago
Sure it worked at reducing hate speech on reddit, but is that the right objective? It's not implausible to think that the resentment from such local measures could cause hate to increase in a more global sense. Kind of like entropy in thermodynamics: local work can reduce local entropy, but at the expense of causing a global increase in entropy.
If the real objective should be a global decrease in hate, then maybe local suppression/exile might not be the right mechanism.
- gremloni 5y agoThe hate is in part generated by a continuous bubbled feedback loop. Cutting out the source(s) usually doesn’t lead to a redirection and rather has a chilling effect.
- simonh 5y agoI suppose to the extent these channels of communication recruit and radicalise, if they are shut down they will not be able to recruit and radicalise. The act of shutting them down might infuriate regular users of these channels, but they’re already radicalised anyway.
- naasking 5y agoThere is little evidence that radicalization happens online [1]. It seems to require in-person contact to really take root. [1] https://www.rand.org/randeurope/research/projects/internet-and-radicalisation.html https://www.rand.org/randeurope/research/projects/internet-a...
- Pils 5y agoThat research was published by a libertarian think tank in 2013. Since then, there have been numerous examples of lone wolf terrorist attacks where the perpetrators appeared to have no offline contacts with extremist groups. See: New Zealand shooting, Pittsburgh shooting, etc.
- fallingknife 5y agoThere were also lone wolf mass shootings before the internet, so what does this prove?
- blitzar 5y agoThat radicalisation does not exclusively happen face to face and that it can be conducted on line, by newsletter, by book, by carrier pigeon.
- xadhominemx 5y agoThis “study” has been proven to be obviously and demonstrably incorrect in the years since it was published. The authors should retract.
- kongin 5y agoI can say that the local subreddit is one of the most heavily policed with the result that during the covid pandemic a large fraction of the casual posters were banned because they couldn't keep track of what new rule was introduced in what day. A lot of people moved over to telegram channels because you could actually ask questions without getting banned for concern trolling, misinformation or incitement - e.g. asking where protests were happening which is what got me banned finally. Ironically I was asking where they were happening so I could avoid them. The result of that policing is that I now have a telegram account and regularly scan a dozen right wing channels so I know if I can buy groceries without getting tear gassed. If this is what winning looks like for the left we don't need help in losing.
- chmsky00 5y agoThe goal is to reduce network effects. As poetic as free speech is, the 1700s were a different time. Hard to SWAT a rando a town away let alone a country. Now a nation state can instigate localized terrorism. Thomas Jefferson understood laws and constitutions must change in step with human discovery. Scalia wrote laws are not open ended, and up for public romantic interpretation. To paraphrase both. Indeed many Founders wrote of the need for free speech in official political proceedings, never considering the privilege extending to the public. In public people were welcome to get a beating if they prefer to violate local order. Humans are biological animals first. Gentile by training.
- Barrin92 5y agoif you read the actual research provided by the OP it shows way more than that. The measures did not only crowd out hate speech, the study followed individual users and noted that they moderated and changed their behavior once they moved to other communities after the more extremist ones were banned, and they individually changed adapted. That implies that the there's a positive effect even on the individual level, not just a silencing effect. Which seems completely in line with say, busting a cult in real life.