11 ms·
A little off topic, but I wish we could stop using this nice-sounding "hesitant" euphemism. Hesitant implies that people are weighing options and open to changi
by ryandrake 5y ago
A little off topic, but I wish we could stop using this nice-sounding "hesitant" euphemism. Hesitant implies that people are weighing options and open to changing their minds. With the amount of time they have been available and the overabundance of evidence that the COVID vaccines are safe, effective, and that they decrease hospitalizations and death, I find it very hard to believe that anyone is still "on the fence" about it.
> She thinks they’re taking it down because they don’t want people to know the truth.
And there it is--this doesn't sound like a person who is weighing their options in good faith. It sounds like someone who is already convinced of what the truth is. Let's stop calling them "hesitant".
- colordrops 5y agoIt's certainly better than "anti-vaxxer" which labels them and buckets them as crazy and makes them dig their heels in further. If the goal is to convince people to get vaccinated, belittling them is not the right approach.
- tomrod 5y agoWhen I was in the process of disassociating from a high demand religion (a decade long process), I was struck with how effective people who insisted on reality were. Reality sounded belittling, but it really wasn't. I see an analogy here with the people insisting against vaccination with zeal and fervor. It is very hard to break through the bubble of cognitive dissonance, and lone/let live or "humor them" approaches frankly are disingenuous.
- colordrops 5y agoStrawman. No one said you shouldn't speak about the truth and reality. I'm saying not to give them a demeaning label.
- tomrod 5y agoshrug. Labels are quite effective for concise communication, all negatives aside. Such as your classification of my point as a strawman (which I don't consider it to be), you communicate a precise response with a single word.
- colordrops 5y agostrawman is a description of your argument, not you. It doesn't make a judgement about what kind of person you are, and that you have been or always will make bad arguments. It's very different from calling you Strawman-er, which would be making unfounded assumptions about your general argumentation style and would pre-judge future statements by you.
- tomrod 5y ago"Anti-vaccine advocate" is clear. It identifies a set of behaviors that are intellectually dishonest, either claiming hesitancy, outright denying science, or (even worse) economically benefitting by sowing confusion. When people don't do this, they aren't advocating against vaccination. My understanding of the strawman fallacy is that the strawman is inaccurate. None is expressed here, simply labeling a phenomenon. > which would be making unfounded assumptions about your general argumentation style and would pre-judge future statements by you. After decades of internet discussion, such charity from people holding opposing viewpoints appears to be rare even when explicitly and rigorously adopted.
- EEMac 5y agoSure. But "anti-vaxxer" has two meanings which are conveniently confused in current usage. 1. Someone against all vaccines 2. Someone against the current COVID vaccines
- tomrod 5y agoAgreed. Anti-vaccine advocate is more accurate at this point. Denialist is harsh, but fits.
- __blockcipher__ 5y agoMost people who are "COVID vaccine hesitant", or whatever term we want to use, aren't opposed to the concept of vaccination in general. Many of them have even gotten flu shots many times in the past, which as an aside when analyzed rigorously are barely better than placebo: https://www.cochrane.org/CD001269/ARI_vaccines-prevent-influenza-healthy-adults https://www.cochrane.org/CD001269/ARI_vaccines-prevent-influ... > Injected influenza vaccines probably have a small protective effect against influenza and ILI (moderate-certainty evidence), as 71 people would need to be vaccinated to avoid one influenza case, and 29 would need to be vaccinated to avoid one case of ILI. Vaccination may have little or no appreciable effect on hospitalisations (low-certainty evidence) or number of working days lost. So 71 shots to avoid one case, or if we want to be charitable we should use the 29 shots per one ILI since really ILI is what we care about. And no actual effect on hosp. or working days lost (both of which is what we should really actually care about) -- Anyway I got off track with the flu vaccine stuff, but anyway surely you're aware that far more people are "hesitant" about the COVID vaccine specifically than any of the other vaccines? So to cast it as a case of "anti-vaccine advocacy" is just wrong. That's not what's going on here and as long as you refuse to try to understand these people you will continue failing to impact their behavior.
- tomrod 5y ago> as you refuse to try to understand these people you will continue failing to impact their behavior. You and I are not responsible for their behavior, and as a society we have entertained their petulance long enough. I support vaccine mandates to increase the social costs for people who fail to perform their civic duty to be vaccinated. (Medically unable is a different story).
- __blockcipher__ 5y agoWell good for you, but you actually do need to look on the impact on behavior of the things you advocate for. Unless your goal is purely to punish/harm those that don't share your beliefs rather than some tangible outcome in terms of vaccination or [insert primary endpoint here]. We're already seeing the impact of vaccine mandates in places like New York: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/covid-vaccine-mandate-new-york-hospital-workers-2021-09-28/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/covid-vaccine-mandate-new-york-... > "We stopped elective inpatient surgeries. We stopped some of our outpatient patient visits. We stopped ICU medical transfers from other referral rural hospitals. ... We've asked for more time to work on strategies with the state to ensure that as many people as possible get vaccinated," said Tom Quatroche, the president and CEO of Erie County Medical Center. I would be remiss if I didn't mention that we already know beyond a shadow of a doubt that mass COVID vaccination doesn't magically stop the virus from doing what it does. Israel has absurdly high vaccine uptake - including a sizeable proportion of triply-vaxxed people - and we're still seeing more "cases" than at the same time the previous year. So I wonder how much you've actually looked into the efficacy (in terms of chance of infection and spread) of these vaccines given the data. And I wonder how rigorously you've thought about the second and third order effects when phenomenoms like antigenic drift and immune escape and Marek's disease are very well known. Anyway, I won't go too far down that rabbit hole since the discussion is more of "assuming vaccination is good and we don't have any ethical qualms with using violent police power to compel people to consume a pharmaceutical product where the manufacturers have literally no liability to the consumer for any adverse reactions, what is the best way to modify behavior" than about examining the premise of the utility of mass vaccination itself. It's probably already obvious that I completely reject the ethics of what you are in favor of. So setting the pesky notion of ethics aside for the time-being, I still think you're failing to see the very obvious harms that come from the brand of coercion that you're advocating for. Like I said above, we're already seeing the effects of these mandates on healthcare capacity. Firing 5% of one's hospital staff is no small thing. And you seem to very much not see how censoring and suppressing alternate points of view only reinforces those points of view. Implicitly you seem to think that adopting a policy and actually enforcing it in the real-world are the same thing - which is a trap that many a naive intellectual has fallen into since time immemorial.
- ghoward 5y agoOh, Mirriam-Webster already decided that "fully vaccinated" people are "anti-vaxxers" if they do not support vaccine mandates. [1] [1]: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/anti-vaxxer https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/anti-vaxxer
- rchaud 5y ago"Webster defines [word] as..." has been a running punchline for over 20 years. I think the dignity of the real anti-vaxxers will remain intact.
- rabuse 5y agoThat is absolutely ridiculous.
- roflc0ptic 5y agoNot really though. If you go back 2 years, people who were opposed to mandatory vaccinations were generally people who thought their children shouldn't be required to get vaccinated against measles. Vaccine mandates are crucial social policy
- mlang23 5y agoNo, they are not crucial social policy. You will have to accept that democracy does not mean that everyone has to be of the same opinion as you.
- Jensson 5y ago> Vaccine mandates are crucial social policy Maybe the reason USA has so many anti vaccers is because of vaccine mandates? It is much easier to believe that something is evil when you are forced to do it. Also many first world countries doesn't mandate vaccines and people get vaccinated anyway, so it isn't crucial social policy.
- rabuse 5y agoExactly. COVID is so deadly, that people have to be coerced and mandated into taking it, when in the beginning of all of this, most were walking around asymptomatic with it.
- __blockcipher__ 5y agoWhile I almost entirely disagree with you, I agree with the general idea that most people aren't "hesitant". Personally I'm vaccine "hell no!" (because I don't have a personal medical need for the COVID vaccine, potential side effects aside, and I reject the societal benefit argument given the population dynamics of what happens when you vaccinate against just the spike). So while I come at it from the total opposite reason, you're right that with the massive amount of propaganda and outright coercion that everyone (at least in the US) has been exposed to over the last several months, most people who are not vaccinated are fairly strongly opposed to getting it (not necessarily all for the same reason). There are definitely a bunch of "I wanna wait and see" type people, but given all the coercion/propaganda they are few and far between.
- arcticbull 5y agoThat's like saying I'm "vaccine hell no!" because I don't have a personal need for a polio vaccine lol. Across the entire spectrum you're at less risk from the vaccine than you are from the disease. > and I reject the societal benefit argument given the population dynamics of what happens when you vaccinate against just the spike That's so weird, all the data seems to indicate that in areas with high vaccination rates nobody gets sick and dies. It feels like you've manufactured a windmill for yourself.
- bwship 5y ago> Across the entire spectrum you're at less risk from the vaccine than you are from the disease. The current survival rate from the virus is at around 99.2%. The vaccine may or may not have long term health effects. How is taking the virus head on less risky?
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoBecause we know for sure that Covid infection causes significant long term damage in at least 10% of cases. So if you want brain damage, scarred lungs, or some other organ malfunction, Covid infection is the way to go. And the longer term risks are still unknown. Which is why it's insane to play evidence-free yes-but-what-if FUD games about vaccine safety when the risks of infection are already known to be high for the survivors. https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/coronavirus/in-depth/coronavirus-long-term-effects/art-20490351 https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/coronavirus/i...
- tbihl 5y ago>I find it very hard to believe that anyone is still "on the fence" about it. >And there it is--this doesn't sound like a person who is weighing their options in good faith. It sounds like someone who is already convinced of what the truth is. Pot, meet kettle.
- sethammons 5y agothat one jumped out at me :)
- browningstreet 5y agoI'm not sure I entirely agree. There are people getting vaccines for the first time every day right now. Somehow they came around.
- randallsquared 5y agoBut lots if these people DO change their minds. I have a relatively small circle of in-person family and friends, and five of the six hesitant people in that group are now covid vaxxed. There are those who will accept no evidence, but most of the "hesitant" aren't in that group.
- zucked 5y agoCurious - what changed their minds?
- ryandrake 5y ago+1 I sincerely want to believe this is true. What information in September was enough to convince them, where they weren't convinced in August (when the vaccines got full FDA approval). EDIT: According to [1] the "Wait and See" bucket is down to about 7% as of September. I'd really love to know what new information they are waiting for. Fascinating! 1: https://www.kff.org/coronavirus-covid-19/poll-finding/kff-covid-19-vaccine-monitor-september-2021/ https://www.kff.org/coronavirus-covid-19/poll-finding/kff-co...
- tomp 5y agoIndeed, I prefer "vaccine redundancy" over "vaccine hesitancy". For people who've had Covid before, vaccine is simply redundant. (If you disagree, please provide sources / data for your view.) Of course, getting vaccinated would increase their immune system's response, but so would for someone who was vaccinated a month ago... at some point, it has to be "good enough" for normal life (not 100% safe anyways).
- darthvoldemort 5y agoIsraeli study says getting infected creates 13x stronger immune response than the vaccine versus Delta. How much stronger do we need to get that justifies taking the vaccine at that point? This is the entire point of why they say vaccine mandates are wrong for those that already had it.
- tomrod 5y agoDelta isn't, and likely, won't be the only variant. Having a broad response via vaccination helps, even if you have antibodies from prior exposure.
- jaywalk 5y agoYou're missing the point. Prior infection creates a much broader response than vaccination does.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tomrod 5y agoNo, the point is clear but missing an essential detail. Vaccination results in much better outcomes when you do get the disease. Ergo the ideal is to be vaccinated, and then if you so happen to get sick, recovery is quicker and you have a stronger immune response.
- 5y ago
- darthvoldemort 5y agoSuch judgmental bullshit. People like you are part of the problem and need to stop. The vaccine is the fastest vaccine EVER approved. We have ZERO long-term data as to what it does. We have a long history of drugs that have long term side effects. For fuck's sake, there are a ton of blood pressure medications that have recently been taken off the market because they have cancer-causing impurities in them. Do you think they cause cancer in 1 year? Of course not. They cause cancer over the long term. Even the people who breathed in the dust from 9-11 took years to die from cancer related to that. Do we know if the mRNA vaccine has any long term effects? We do not. If you say they are 100% safe long term, then you are lying. We simply don't have the data. We will definitely have the data over the next several years in what is now the world's biggest medical experiment in history. And by the way, I'm fully vaccinated and I was vaccinated before you were. But I UNDERSTAND why people are hesitant. I was hesitant as well until I was presented with the vaccine and I said fuck it, let's go. But I completely empathize with those that are hesitant. That's what we need more of, empathy. Not judgmental jerks who just prolong the schism between people.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tomrod 5y agoHow long do the components of the vaccine stay in the body before being consumed? Is DNA changed? Do you have a specific pathway you think the mRNA vaccine conponents takes that you think will cause long term effects? Why is the more traditional approaches taken by J&J not acceptable if there is fear regarding mRNA vaccines?
- matt_f 5y agoThis strikes me as entirely being exactly the things of which you are accuse the parent post's author. > "people like you are part of the problem" > "such judgemental bullshit" > "judgmental jerks who prolong the schism between people" Whatever your positions or beliefs on the matter, or opinions of the post author to whom you are responding, your opinions and views could be more effectively expressed using logic and reasoning without the ad hominem and vulgarity. In any regard: it's beneath the community standards of reasoned and respectful communication on HN, which I think many of us highly appreciate and value.
- mlang23 5y agoAt this point in time, nobody not vaccinated yet is interested in your propaganda. Also, the post you are replying to is already sort of doxing his own wife, so please dont make it even worse by capitalising on that.
- mlang23 5y agoRight, people like you need to be stopped. Lets stop talking to people like you, and support them in our community. Lets stop helping people like you if they need something. Lets just drop people like you out of society.
- nsxwolf 5y agoGiven that there have been 20 million vaccine doses administered in the US during the month of September, it would seem that you are wrong. The vaccine has been available for many months. Certainly some of those 20 million doses represent people who have been hesitating for one reason or another.
- batch12 5y agoIf it is an established truth that these vaccines are safe, why still grant these companies immunity from liability if something goes wrong? Before someone dismisses the question as anti-vaxxer, I have taken the vaccine.
- dang 5y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28694236 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28694236.
- Thuggery 5y ago> overabundance of evidence that the COVID vaccines are safe, effective, and that they decrease hospitalizations and death "evidence" that comes from tightly controlled information sources with clear non-truth oriented motivations, that can only accept one answer, and suppres all contrary evidence and discourse? Well if Pravda and the Party tell us the injection is a must and safe too then who could ever doubt it? I was (and am?) "vaccine hesitant." I am vaccinated now, though it was probably unnecessary since I already had it. I'm really starting to wonder what exactly they injected into me and almost regret it. These are not the actions benevolent actors with nothing to hide. FYI what pushed me over he edge was a combination of discomfort (wanted to occasionally re-engage with nightlife without worry and guilt), time, local community that I trusted more getting it, and some people in particular I wanted to meet up with that were particularly anal about covid fears.