3 ms·
New Zealand has a Censorship Office and an official called the Chief Censor. The government has the power to declare that certain communications are illegal and
by bitwize 5y ago
New Zealand has a Censorship Office and an official called the Chief Censor. The government has the power to declare that certain communications are illegal and prosecute people for making those communications. They recently, famously did this with footage from the Christchurch shootings as well as the shooter's manifesto.
Yet New Zealand consistently tops Cato Institute's freedom index.
Maybe, just maybe, an absolutist reading of free speech that favors spreading of hate and misinformation, as we have in the USA ever since Brandenburg v. Ohio in 1969[0] is not a necessary condition for freedom. Maybe restricting speech actually has a public benefit and can increase the freedom and well-being of individuals with no hateful or dishonest intent.
[0] Note that the plaintiff was a KKK member, so yes, the current bedrock court ruling for free speech in the USA was crafted specifically to protect hate speech.
- Jiro 5y agoIf you can ban something for being hate speech, calling something hate speech becomes a weapon. I absolutely don't trust any of the people banning "hate speech" to not have double standards that make it easy to call anything politically disagreeing with them "hate speech".
- BitwiseFool 5y ago>"Yet New Zealand consistently tops Cato Institute's freedom index." Good for them, but that that index is meaningless to me. Truthfully, I have no respect for arguments that twist acts of suppressing freedom into acts seen as enhancing or preserving freedom.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoFrom a personal perspective, I don't want to have to wade through everyone else's "free expression", for the same reason that I don't want to have to wade through every company's advertisements. Experientially, I am less free when everyone can interrupt my brain space with what they want to shove at me. I want limited amounts of high-quality, interesting communication, not the noise of everybody's everything. (Think in terms of Shannon information theory.) So I kind of see your point. Filtering out the garbage is no loss to me. It make me freer rather than less free. And yet... The failure mode of the New Zealand approach is to have someone who is partisan hold the office of Chief Censor. Worse, someone who is a dedicate partisan might see the value of holding that position, and might deliberately, systematically seek it, hiding their partisan-ness until they obtained it. Sooner or later, someone's going to at least try.
- mardifoufs 5y ago>Yet New Zealand consistently tops Cato Institute's freedom index. Well I'm sure those who got arrested for sharing the Christchurch footage (footage that was, btw, widely available and shared worldwide) will be happy to hear that. They may be in jail but at least the Cato institute declared that they were still living in a country that tops their index. An index that hasn't even changed or taken in consideration the extreme drift towards authoritarianism that we have seen in the 2020.