3 ms·
People forget that politics is preference. Science deals in the objective while politics deals in the subjective (preferences).
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
People forget that politics is preference.
Science deals in the objective while politics deals in the subjective (preferences).
- OrvalWintermute 5y agoI don't know how objective science is, because we bring all of our biases to the table when we interpret data. A young earth creationist, an old earth creationist, a fanatical darwin evolutionist, and an ardent panspermia UFOlogist are all going to view the same data very different, even if they have identical educational credentials. The holes in evidence for each don't matter, because they are the persuaded. If we think about truth bending to subjective reality, I am sure certain that some of the churchmen & scientists opposing Galileo's embrace of Copernican heliocentrism were completely certain geocentrism was the truth because their own astronomical observations were subject to slavish obedience to doctrine. This doctrine in their heads influenced their own observations. Narrative overwhelmed the senses. It is the mad among us that have the rare ability to completely discount all external input and see a thing for what it truely is. And, that is why we call them crazy.
- tremon 5y agoI don't know how objective science is, because we bring all of our biases to the table when we interpret data You are conflating "science" and "scientist" here. The way science overcomes bias is two-fold: 1) by training scientists to be aware of their own biases, and 2) by having multiple scientists, each with their own biases, try to reproduce the same experimental results. Your artificial example is just that, they all fail 1).
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoScience is conducted by people, all of whom have preferences. Until the day arrives that science is explored only by preferenceless beings, science and politics will continue to have a significant overlap, much of it at the invitation of scientists.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoYes, what is studied by scientists is based on preference (and therefore politics).
- Nursie 5y agoThe problem comes when preference has been based on something that becomes shown objectively false. People are so attached to their preference that they dismiss facts and attack the whole concept of knowledge to maintain that preference.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoWho has the objective falsifications? Is it actually a preference of risk reduction and complexity? Would be interested to hear your example.
- Nursie 5y agoFor instance when science shows that burning fossil fuels causes environmental problems. Rational preference would be to take that into account and consider risks and potential mitigation into the preference to keep using them. What we observe in much of the political sphere however, is often just abject denial to maintain the current preference.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoGood example. I wonder if those in power who make money from coal plants know that they are causing some harm while they are causing some good (providing power) just prefer to deal with the pollution issues after they are dead :)