6 ms·
They talked about stack of libraries beneath you, not the execution stack. If an API call takes 10 microseconds because several "premature optimization is the r
by Jensson 5y ago
They talked about stack of libraries beneath you, not the execution stack. If an API call takes 10 microseconds because several "premature optimization is the root of all evil" abstractions in between then doing that just 10k times already nets you 100ms which is a very noticeable stutter. So with that limitation you are now forced to create elaborate data structures with caching etc to try to work around this slow API call. However doing the same querying in C++ without those abstractions where each call takes 10 nanoseconds means that you no longer have to try to create complex data structures to work around that slow API call, even if you do it a million times it would only take 10 milliseconds and maybe drop a frame.
- npigrounet 5y agoNowadays JS is as fast as C++, if not faster.
- goldenkey 5y agoLet me respond for him. He meant abstraction as in "stack of dependencies." Because everyone knows that's what abstraction means, right?! Because we all know NPM is a disaster as opposed to C++ dependency management which doesn't even exist in a standard form. /s
- Jensson 5y agoMicrosoft has a C++ API you use to make programs for windows. If you write in C++ you will code directly against that. If you write in Javascript then you will code against someone else's API that they wrote to interface with the Microsoft API. If you write in Javascript another step up then you will code your plugin against the VSCode API which then uses the Electrons wrapper around Microsofts API to do stuff, if there aren't more libraries in between. This stack of abstractions turned out to be too slow to solve the problem mentioned in the article we are talking about, so to solve it they moved the entire thing up one step in the stack. In these situations it is common to have a problem that is really easy to solve but the API abstractions you have to work with doesn't support the operations at the speeds you need to solve it. If you have never experienced that then you aren't working on performance intensive projects where every bit counts and your input on this topic doesn't matter. I have worked on performance intensive libraries crossing programming language boundaries and the abstraction boundaries absolutely puts a limit on the amount of performance you can get. Well designed abstractions are less obstructive but plenty of them aren't well designed and even the well designed ones have overhead.
- npigrounet 5y agoJS is almost close to the metal nowadays thanks to the stunningly optimized JIT.
- amw-zero 5y agoCan you initialize a kernel with JS?
- goldenkey 5y agoOf course. Have you not seen the VMs written in JS? https://bellard.org/jslinux/ https://bellard.org/jslinux/
- amw-zero 5y agoThat is a VM running in a web browser. If I was thinking about a joke that was so comically far away from the metal, that’s pretty much what I would use as an example. This is why it’s very difficult to have conversations. Most programmers really don’t even know how computers work.
- goldenkey 5y agoHeh, I know plenty about how computers work. You didn't specify what hardware you wanted targeted. Emulated devices are just abstractions. Here is a real kernel: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7958194 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7958194 It's so difficult to have conversations with engineers that don't know x86 assembly. They never stop complaining. If only I could NOP them! ;-)
- goldenkey 5y agoAh, so this is all coming from a Microsoft C++ guy. Well better get to using those undocumented ntdll calls since you really need those uOps. It's not like the standard libraries of other languages is written in C or anything... ;-)
- 5y ago