3 ms·
Packaging a movie is something that only needs to be done once right? Like filming the shots, hiring the actors, and writing the script? So why does a few ho
by londons_explore 5y ago
Packaging a movie is something that only needs to be done once right? Like filming the shots, hiring the actors, and writing the script?
So why does a few hours matter in a total process which is many months or even years?
- maverwa 5y agoFrom what I understand, this is using in the production itself as well, potentially for steps inbetween? Especially the"The Conclusion" reads like its not a one-time thing but happens through the whole process?
- wongarsu 5y agoYes, the intro mentions "cloud-based post-production editing and collaboration pipelines", and the conclusion is "This significantly improves the Studio high quality proxy generation efficiency". While the article avoids mentioning why they actually need this, it reads like they have some collaboration platform for post-production of their own productions, and that involves frequent exports into a streamable format.
- MontyCarloHall 5y agoI assume that not all encodings of every movie are stored in perpetuity, to save space. Thus, sometimes they need to be regenerated on-demand, which is why efficiency is important.
- endisneigh 5y agoWhy not though? Isn’t storage cheap compared to compute? Hell, compared to the cost to license the movie storage is pennies.
- MontyCarloHall 5y agoI’m sure someone at Netflix did the cost/benefit analysis and found that for extremely infrequently accessed encodings of certain movies (weird bitrate/resolution combinations), it’s actually cheaper to generate them dynamically once in a blue moon than to store them in perpetuity. > Hell, compared to the cost to license the movie storage is pennies. Yup. I’d be very curious to see the breakdown in how much Netflix spends on compute versus content production/licensing. I’d be willing to bet compute is an order or two of magnitude cheaper than content. I guess all these little optimizations add up? Or maybe their engineering management can’t see the forest from the trees.
- twistedpair 5y agoI suspect they spend much more on transit than compute.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- amitport 5y agoOnce or a few times. It still saves money. Certainly in the Netflix scale. You invest some in engineering and you will save constant percentage $$ in the Netflix scale. Many smaller distributors don't invest internally in this kind of things (and don't have the internal engineering to achieve this). They will buy of-the-shelves solutions though.
- kevindong 5y agoIf the initial cost is x engineer hours and each hour costs $y, that implies the cost of the project is `x * $y + maintenance costs [of this system over the simpler, original approach]` Is the increased speed worth `x * $y + maintenance costs`? Could it pay off? Potentially yes. Will it actually pay off? I don't know since there's far too many variables to wildly speculate on. But I hope Netflix did the accounting at some point along the way to find out. Not every improvement is worth building since the initial investment might grossly overshadow any potential gains (as a purely hypothetical situation, that's why you shouldn't spend $1 million up front to save $1/day for the next 30 years).