3 ms·
Statements like "local poor people eat meat regularly." are just flat out ignorant. http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/1990/09/how-poor-are-americas-poor
by patio11 15y ago
Statements like "local poor people eat meat regularly." are just flat out ignorant.
http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/1990/09/how-poor-are-americas-poor http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/1990/09/how-poor-ar...
Search for "Food Consumption of Poor Children", read the following two paragraphs. USDA data shows poor people eat a) more protein than non-poor people (yes, really), b) more meat than average citizens of many rich nations (like Japan or the UK), and c) vastly more meat than average citizens of Mexico/Brazil/etc.
- ambler0 15y agoYou do realize that the "research" you cite comes from an ultra-rightwing think tank, right? They have a longstanding agenda of trying to make people believe that poverty doesn't exist in America.
- tptacek 15y agoUh huh. http://www.fns.usda.gov/oane/MENU/Published/CNP/FILES/NHANES-NSLP.pdf http://www.fns.usda.gov/oane/MENU/Published/CNP/FILES/NHANES... Data from the National School Lunch Program suggests the same thing. Protein deficiency is not statistically a challenge faced by Americans living below the poverty line. You can disagree with Heritage's politics (I certainly do), but it's naive to suggest that they're simply fabricating their underlying data.
- ambler0 15y agoI didn't suggest an outright fabrication. No need to restate here all of the cliches about how statistics can be manipulated. My only suggestion was that the Heritage Foundation are an absolutely worthless source. If you've provided a better one, that's great. Even if we grant that protein deficiency itself is not a huge problem for America's poor, it nevertheless remains that the protein (and food generally) available to our poor is of the lowest quality.
- tptacek 15y agoSince Heritage here provided data that ultimately appears to be correct, your assertion that it's a "worthless" source isn't borne out, and so I'm less inclined to pursue a tangent about protein "quality" with you. That's too bad, because I have a lot of thoughts about protein quality, and I think you'd probably agree with them. Unfortunately, you're in a place where you seem more inclined to troll threads with politics, so, maybe some other time.
- ambler0 15y agoI disagree with your logic here. To my mind, there are many sources that are absolutely not worth wasting any time on who may nevertheless say true things from time to time. I think you'd be hard pressed to find a source that tells only lies. Heritage's data come from a Dept of Ag study. This seems like an excellent example of why we should try to cite original authors instead of intermediaries. I honestly didn't mean to do anything trollish. And what's with "quality" in scare quotes?
- tptacek 15y agoThe guy who attempts to refute an apparently correct study by putting the word "research" in scare quotes doesn't get to complain about other people's quotation marks, but for what it's worth, I'm a local protein guy. Next time someone who does not share your exact political beliefs (or your orthodoxy in ensuring that his/her tertiary sources have unimpeachable credentials), I suggest you actually read what they're saying and come back with facts. The reality is that in a community of professionals, you're unlikely to find yourself conversing solely with people who agree with your worldview. The irony is, I probably do agree with your politics, but I find the way you handled this particular wrinkle of the discussion so repellant that I've been driven somewhat apey.
- ambler0 15y agoI had totally forgotten that I had put "research" in scare quotes. You're right: it turned out to be unwarranted. That having been said, I think you misunderstand me. I'm quite eager to learn from people who don't share my beliefs; it's the only reason I spend any time slogging through these comments in the first place. The spirit of my original reply, and what I should have said, is that bringing the Heritage Foundation into the discussion can only serve to muddle things.
- rlander 15y ago1990? Really?
- tptacek 15y agoThe data for 2001 and 2004 is out there and does not appear to show a sudden swing away from protein consumption for low-income Americans.
- burgerbrain 15y agoheritage.org? You have to be fucking kidding me. Do you even know who they are?
- patio11 15y agoThey appear to be the group with USDA data to back up their claims regarding a measurable fact of material reality. If you have better data, please, do share.
- tptacek 15y agoThis is a content free comment. Please stop sucking the oxygen out of the thread. Nutrition information specific to the US cross-tabbed by income is a pain in the ass to find, but it is out there. If you want to refute a study, you'll actually have to refute it, not simply cast aspersions on its authors.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- swah 15y agoIs chicken meat?