2 ms·
Coming from a country (Australia) where federal elections are 100% run by and under control of an (independent) federal agency – I wonder how much of the recent
by skissane 5y ago
Coming from a country (Australia) where federal elections are 100% run by and under control of an (independent) federal agency – I wonder how much of the recent US controversies over voting are due to the fact that the implementation of federal elections is something under state (and often even local) control?
Would a "federal takeover" improve things? Have the FEC (or maybe even a new successor agency) actually run presidential and congressional elections?
Of course, I realise it is very unlikely that legislation for such a "federal takeover" would make it through Congress, and if they did, there is a high likelihood that SCOTUS (especially with their current majority) would strike it down as an unconstitutional encroachment on state's rights.
- simondotau 5y agoThere are no controversies here because we have compulsory voting, which means that it's impractical to try to legislatively suppress the vote.
- skissane 5y agoProblem with that argument: in New Zealand, they have non-compulsory voting, but New Zealand doesn't have those kinds of controversies either. That's why I don't think compulsory voting really works as an explanation, despite the fact that it is the first thing to pop into many Australians' heads. In fact, most Western countries are like New Zealand – lack of compulsory voting (unlike Australia), lack of any major controversies over the integrity of the voting system (unlike the US)