3 ms·
The Grievance Studies hoax is of course literal trolling. But I think you’re giving these fields too much credit as a baseline. The four published articles seem
by rayiner 5y ago
The Grievance Studies hoax is of course literal trolling. But I think you’re giving these fields too much credit as a baseline. The four published articles seem plenty ridiculous to me: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grievance_studies_affair https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grievance_studies_affair
- tptacek 5y agoThe articles are ridiculous. The point is that they didn't get published anywhere meaningful, and that they were deceptive about what did and didn't get published. If they're willing to be deceptive about something as silly as this, why should I think they're unwilling to be deceptive about other stuff?
- rayiner 5y agoFair point. I haven’t dug into the reporting they did on it.
- edanm 5y agoI seem to remember `tptacek (and others) criticizing the Grievances affair when it first gained attention. One of the other criticisms was that the papers weren't quite as crazy as they sounded from the title alone. I haven't done so again, but I seem to remember reading one of them when they were published, and indeed, while a bit of a funny premise, the actual report seemed to actually be interesting and actually deserved publication (assuming the data wasn't faked obviously). I seem to remember that the more outlandish-sounding papers were the ones that weren't published, and the ones that were published were the more reasonable ones, too.
- mieses 5y agoIs it wrong to be deceptive? The anti-racists believe that the the telos of the academy is social justice not truth. Truth is a western and racist value. On the other hand, your critique is good because it attacks the right group, despite being based on the racist notion of truth.