7 ms·
High-profile autism genetics project paused amid backlash
- magnetowasright 5y agoGreat! I’m so glad this is becoming an issue that bigger publications actually discuss. It’s disgusting that this even got as far as it did before it was put on hold, but it’s still progress. I’m laughing/crying at the last quote there about how the researchers should have known better when the researchers are some of the top names in publishing contentious, dehumanising, unrepeatable, unscientific claims about Autism and Autistics. These people have made their careers off the back of refusing to understand, meaningfully engage, and ironically empathise with Autistic folks. I suppose this is a step in the right direction, though. It’s being talked about. I hope things are really changing.
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoHmm, I'm not sure what the best solution is but having open, unrestricted access seems like the better solution. > Concerns about the study include fears that its data could potentially be misused by other researchers seeking to ‘cure’ or eradicate ASD. There is a fine line here. The average person would be better off not having ASD just like they would be better off not being 'deaf'. Unless you disagree which gets into a tricky area. Leaving a person's abilities up to chance is arbitrary and doesn't solve anything. Unfortunately we can't let everyone decide for themselves since these decisions are done prior or soon after birth. Restricting a parent's ability to decide the health of their offspring also seems more wrong until you realize a parent could decide to make their offspring deaf, blind, etc.
- klipt 5y agoI think it's fine for parents to decide. If deaf parents want deaf kids and hearing parents want hearing kids those are both valid. Their kids their choice.
- esyir 5y agoHell no. You're telling me that it's in the domain of parents to knowingly cripple their kids sensory function? That's absurd.
- klipt 5y agoWould you say people with a gene for deafness shouldn't be allowed to reproduce? That would open a whole can of worms. What if some society says black skin is a disability so black people shouldn't be allowed to reproduce?
- esyir 5y agoThere's a clear line between stopping reproduction and intentionally inducing disabilities. I'm going to put it another way. Does this really pass your own personal sanity check? That parents should be allowed to: - Amputate their children's limbs (Various developmental defects - Remove their children's eyes (Blindness) - Perforate their children's eardrums (Deafness) - Remove their tongue / vocal chords (Mutes) - Paralyze their kids (Various forms of musculoskeletal issues) - Inflict brain damage on their kids (various forms of intellectual disabilities)
- ghuin 5y agoOr remove their foreskins :')
- Dracophoenix 5y agoThere are medical reasons for the removal of foreskins such as phimosis [1]. Inasmuch as I would agree that religious justifications for circumcision are the ramblings of a cargo cult, circumcision itself was and is (for now at least) not without value. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phimosis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phimosis
- 5y ago
- pvaldes 5y agoSo the problem is that too much people could be trying to help this people? > a parent could decide to make their offspring deaf, blind, etc. Not, they couldn't do it without a lot of external help. And then, everybody in that team would go to jail. Society shouldn't move following the insane outliers. This would be like saying that as a psycho could drive a car against somebody, we all should stay away from cars.
- dTal 5y agoYou don't really need a huge team to make a child blind or deaf. Just a pointy stick.
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoExactly. But would it get to the point that not fixing/preventing deafness, blindness, ASD, etc. will also be impossible and/or socially stigmatized?
- pvaldes 5y agoI don't think so. Most probably would end being a question of how much money you have. People that currently can't afford rock star level healthcare are not stigmatized for that.
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoIt's called spectrum for a reason: not all forms are disadvantageous. You just incorrectly believe it has only one form that Hollywood likes to show.
- djyaz1200 5y ago"not all forms are disadvantageous" <- this! Some of the most talented and happy people I've ever worked with were "on the spectrum". Our society has a reflex to make everything different a disease instead of acknowledging and celebrating our differences.
- mywittyname 5y agoNot having the ability to properly interact or socialize with people is a pretty significant handicap, IMHO. Sure, a person with ASD and a high intelligence can eventually find a place in society. It's the people with average intelligence and ASD that suffer.
- djyaz1200 5y agoI see your point. It's likely I'm only seeing the people who thrive. The problem is whose definition of "properly interact" are we going with? In my experience people on the spectrum tend towards extreme honesty. What they often aren't good at is understanding all the lies, half truths and hints that are part of socializing... in part to protect the brittle egos most of the rest of us have.
- mywittyname 5y agoSocial awkwardness is a component of ASD, and can be a huge burden for people with it. It really doesn't matter whose definition we go with for what constitutes "proper interactions." Clinically speaking, ASD can cause people to have a difficult time with verbal communication in general, and reading cues of people. This goes far beyond just being too honest. The inability to make friends due to the behavioral issues that arise from living with ASD is torturous. It's probably why ASD is also linked with depression. If I weren't intelligent enough to work a technical job where people don't need to interact me, I probably wouldn't be around today.
- dTal 5y ago>Leaving a person's abilities up to chance is arbitrary and doesn't solve anything It solves the problem of fairly allocating traits which are important to have in a society, but for some reason are not preferred. Humans cannot be trusted with complete genetic control. An extreme example would be China's combination of highly sexist society and one-child policy leading to everyone wanting boys and not girls, leading to a demographic catastrophe. Imagine how much worse it would have been if parents could freely and reliably choose the sex of their offspring, instead of having to sneakily murder their infant daughters.
- tfehring 5y agoThese seem like fair criticisms of the details around e.g. data usage and privacy, but the study itself seems incredibly valuable and I hope it goes forward as planned with suitable data protections in place. Based on the critical comments quoted in the article, it unfortunately seems like the loudest voices in the community - who absolutely don't speak for everyone on the spectrum - have deeper issues with the topic of study itself and will just find other, misguided reasons to try to cancel it anyway. Related reading: https://slatestarcodex.com/2015/10/12/against-against-autism-cures/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2015/10/12/against-against-autism...
- someguydave 5y agoMany people are in denial about how much genes affect people’s behavior and life outcomes. This is ironic considering that “diversity” is held up as an ideal.
- inglor_cz 5y agoThe trouble with most communities is that they do not really hold elections. As a result, anyone loud enough can sell themselves as an "advocate" and make demands, regardless of the real level of support they enjoy among their peers.
- Dma54rhs 5y ago"A genetic study would be terrifying for lots of autistic people; there’s a long-established and well-known history around eugenics and disability,” - can anyone help my understand why that would be problematic? We screen for down syndrome and most of the western world don't see abortion as a murder, why would it be problem to screen and let women decide for autism as well?
- ghuin 5y agoBecause some people seem to think autism is a cool personality trait more than a disability.
- JPLeRouzic 5y ago> We screen for Down's syndrome Maybe the problem is where a policy, practice or simply prejudice would draw a line. There is autism in my family, some members are officially diagnosed, and while it's not my case (I was born in France in the 1950'), I am certainly not someone with an ordinary world view. Otherwise I managed to have a good enough career, sometimes managing up to 100 people. The idea that I could have been "suppressed" because some prejudice is frightening.
- Dma54rhs 5y agoI understand it very well from your point of view but a person living with down syndrome is capable enough to understand and ask the same question. And if he can't it still begs the same question because we don't see as unborn until x weeks as human yet, that would cancel it out. Otherwise we could use the same argument for every aborted unborn?
- esyir 5y agoYou could also have been "suppressed" because of general abortion, something that's typically done for the convenience of the parent. If we support abortion rights, there shouldn't be issues with the termination of foeti for autism/downs/other developmental issues either.
- 5y ago
- PostOnce 5y ago"Study aimed at collecting DNA from 10,000 people with autism and their families has drawn criticism for failing to consult the autism community." ...it sounds like they consulted / planned to consult at least 10,000 members of it.