4 ms·
> Hi, propagandist? Personal attacks are against site rules, and you've been here long enough that you should know that. > China had no ambition for territori
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
> Hi, propagandist?
Personal attacks are against site rules, and you've been here long enough that you should know that.
> China had no ambition for territorial expansion other than defending herself. That's the pattern for 2 thousands years.
China occupied Tibet. China invaded Vietnam twice. The first time, they stayed for a thousand years. "China has no ambition for territorial expansion" only if you accept China's definition of what is rightfully China. A bunch of us don't, though. For that matter, a bunch of nations don't.
Specifically with regard to Taiwan: Yes, China has a historical claim on Taiwan. (And, yes, Taiwan has a historical claim on the mainland.) Technically, as you say it is a civil war.
Practically, it's two countries. They have two militaries, issue two different passports, have two different currencies, etc. Neither one wants to admit this, but de facto they are two separate countries. (So are North and South Korea, even though that civil war legally isn't over either.)
So, legal fictions aside, for China to conquer Taiwan would be a dramatic increase of their actual territory. (That's kind of implied in the word "conquer".)
And it's clearly China that's the aggressor here. Nobody's talking about Taiwan invading and conquering the mainland. But China talks about invading if Taiwan even dares to say that they're a separate country. They act like, if we all play pretend with them, it makes their claim more legitimate or something.
Speaking of legitimacy, let's note that Taiwan is the legitimate government of China. The mainland is held by the rebels.
- justicezyx 5y agoI think we are just speaking the same thing. You might assume that I sided with China mainland. Well, that not where I stand. Neither do I side with Taiwan, nor US. I stand with the safety and prosperity of people.
- masterof0 5y agoIt doesn't matter, you are not allowed to point out hypocrisy, as is not immoral to criticize another government while your own kills children with drone strikes. Is the way it is, I learned the good old *downvoted* way. There is, it seems, a list of things you cannot criticize over here: Rust, US, React JS, Firefox, Elon Musk, Tesla, etc...
- dotancohen 5y ago> only if you accept China's definition of what is rightfully China. And under what pretense do you or your government have more authority to declare "what is rightfully China" than the Chinese?
- rini17 5y agoThat's exactly what governments do. And private persons with human rights have the authority to name territorial conquest by its rightful name.
- dotancohen 5y agoAlright then. With the authority vested in my by HN comment #28691569 (2021-09-29, rini17) I hereby declare all expansion ambitions of the United States of America on the North American continent after 1776 as territorial conquest. Furthermore, I declare all United Nations military presence on soil not under US control in 1776, especially soil not on the North American continent, to be territorial conquest.
- rini17 5y agoNow notice how no one is going to "harmonize" you.
- dotancohen 5y agoCan you restate that? I honestly don't understand.
- sudosysgen 5y agoNot anymore that it is an unshakable fact and it doesn't matter what you think. Go back in 1790 or 1810 and see yourself jailed as a traitor.
- rini17 5y agoCan you restate that? I honestly don't understand.