2 ms·
I don't understand what people think they're saying when they use this weird factoid. People don't want to spend much money dealing with climate change? Well,
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
I don't understand what people think they're saying when they use this weird factoid.
People don't want to spend much money dealing with climate change? Well, that seems reasonable, so we should use the most effective and efficient methods to deal with it, so we institute a carbon tax and use the full power of modern capitalism to generate solutions cheaply.
No wait, it seems we're actually arguing that people do want to spend more money than that on climate change, as long as you don't use it to apply price incentives but instead tax it in some non carbon related manner and hand it out as subsidies?
Though in this specific case, Apple is arguing to not fund it through corporate tax rises, which could be seen as a generic tax on everything, which I'd kind of agree with. I want the corporations releasing fossil carbon (equivalents) into the air to pay more, not some random company, because then they have an incentive to stop doing so.
- rsj_hn 5y ago> Well, that seems reasonable, so we should use the most effective and efficient methods to .. [do what people are strongly opposed to doing] Not sure why this is so hard to understand, but people don't support these types of taxes and if you try to force them on people, you will be thrown out of power and all of your policies reversed by the blowblack, including the subsidies. In fact you will find even extra taxes piled onto "clean" power by the blowback. You can't just unleash a personal inner-dictator and try to force people to do something they have no desire to do. In a democracy, that is quite difficult. There is a reason why, despite 20 years of trying, the green movement has not been able to get this legislation passed. There is no reason to believe that merely with the passage of time, highly unpopular policies will become popular. What has gotten passed is subsidies for green energy. Subsidies are popular. And in a low IR environment, it's great opportunity to heavily invest in nuclear, hydro, and R&D for cheaper, cleaner energy sources that increase, rather than decrease, people's standard of living. The future is one of cheap, abundant power and increasing energy usage per capita, as has been the historical trend. Moreover historically power has always been subsidized, not taxed (on net). There is no future in an agenda of taxing or rationing energy.