7 ms·
If you host blobs for free, somebody is going to use you as their host. Even if you just hosted audio, I'm sure somebody will quickly come along with a steganog
by jfengel 5y ago
If you host blobs for free, somebody is going to use you as their host. Even if you just hosted audio, I'm sure somebody will quickly come along with a steganography tool to hide their content on your site (and use your bandwidth).
Similarly, if you make compute power available, people will use you to mine cryptocurrency. Even if all you host is text, somebody will come along to be abusive. When you put a computer on the Internet, it's open to the entire world, including the very worst people.
If you're hosting a community, start from the beginning by knowing who your community is and how they will tell you who they are. If the answer is "everybody", then know what everybody means -- it means some people won't want to be there, because some people will make life hard for them.
It's no longer 1991, when you could assume that such people wouldn't find you. They will find you -- for money, or the lulz. You have to plan for that on day 1. You can't fix it after the fact.
- htrp 5y ago> If you host blobs for free, somebody is going to use you as their host. Even if you just hosted audio, I'm sure somebody will quickly come along with a steganography tool to hide their content on your site (and use your bandwidth). This feels like something more of a theoretical example cited versus something that has happened. Do you have any examples of steganography being used as bandwidth redirection/hosting?
- joshuamorton 5y agohttps://handwiki.org/wiki/GmailFS https://handwiki.org/wiki/GmailFS https://github.com/maxchehab/redditfs https://github.com/maxchehab/redditfs etc etc.
- michaelpb 5y agoNot at all theoretical, this happens all the time. There are tools like StegoShare: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/StegoShare https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/StegoShare I googled and one of the top articles was this (I didn't read it): https://www.deccanchronicle.com/technology/in-other-news/070817/worrying-trend-in-hackers-using-steganography.html https://www.deccanchronicle.com/technology/in-other-news/070... I couldn't find the article I had read a few years back, but I remember this sort of thing being used to host content on Facebook, Wikipedia, Reddit, etc, before they cracked down on it.
- jcun4128 5y agoRecently saw a post about using imgur to host websites by the website code embedded in images (steganography?)
- TravisHusky 5y agoI did this when I was in high school for fun. I used a poorly designed comment system somebody designed and used it to transfer files around hidden in gibberish comments. Maybe not the most common thing, but more common than you would expect.
- MauranKilom 5y agoMany examples (maybe not exactly steganography, but same spirit) in this discussion from three weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28431716 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28431716
- michaelpb 5y agoYeah, there's an entire category of "idea guys" who don't get this. They repeatedly try to crack the code on a truly moderation-free or purely crowd-moderated platform, and it never, ever, ever works. It almost always boils down to a poor understanding of how humans work (usually some sort of "homo economicus") or how computers work (usually some sort of "AI magic wand").
- seph-reed 5y agoI still theorize crowd-moderated platforms are possible, as long as there's really good gate-keeping. My bet is some real-world tie, one which is time consuming and expensive to create. From there it should be possible to create moderation tools that keep the rest going. An example of a real world tie would be a trust network that requires status with in-person communities and local businesses. And not just "accept the hot chick friend request," but an explicit "I'm staking my reputation by saying this person is real." But once you let bots in, it's over.
- snowwrestler 5y agoSlashdot’s meta-moderation system worked well for a long time. One set of people could make moderation decisions directly on content, and then another unrelated set of people would review the moderation decisions and support or revert them. It was all tied to karma and permissions in ways I can’t quite remember. But essentially there was no way for a motivated bad-faith group to both moderate and meta-moderate themselves, and the incentives marginalized bad faith actors over time.
- nemo44x 5y agoYou had limited resources to use (5 moderation points at a time for example), at least in theory. Having moderation be moderated was a great idea though I think should come back in some form.
- WorldMaker 5y agoModeration is labor and you get what you pay for. Which is not that crowd-moderation cannot work, but that for good crowd-moderation you still have to treat it as a labor pool, have a very good idea of how you are incentivizing/paying for it, and what "metrics/qualities" those incentives are designed to optimize for. (In some cases it actually is far cheaper to pay a small moderator pool a good wage than to pay an entire community a bad wage to "crowd-moderate" if you actually test the business plan versus alternatives.)
- pjc50 5y ago> Even if you just hosted audio Absolute worst case! You're going to end up DMCA'd by the entire music industry. > It's no longer 1991, when you could assume that such people wouldn't find you. Even back in the nineties, there was abuse .. but the internet was so much smaller, and it was possible to manually ban them. Except on USENET. The labour of dealing with spam fell to a small number of people, one of whom wrote this astonishing rant: https://www.eyrie.org/~eagle/writing/rant.html https://www.eyrie.org/~eagle/writing/rant.html (and partly disowned it, but I think he was right first time)
- Sohcahtoa82 5y ago> Absolute worst case! You're going to end up DMCA'd by the entire music industry. You'll even get DMCA'd for your own content! In late 2018, musician TheFatRat had one of his YouTube videos taken down due to a DMCA report: https://twitter.com/thisisthefatrat/status/1072933046939193344?lang=en https://twitter.com/thisisthefatrat/status/10729330469391933... Herman Li, the lead guitarist for Dragonforce, had his Twitch account suspended due to supposed DMCA violations because he played his own music on stream: https://www.kotaku.com.au/2020/10/twitch-dragonforce-herman-li-suspends-channel/ https://www.kotaku.com.au/2020/10/twitch-dragonforce-herman-...
- mijustin 5y ago> If you host blobs for free This is the key distinction. If you charge money, from the beginning, most of your content moderation woes go away. At Transistor.fm we host podcasts and charge money for it (starting at $19/month). We've had very little problems with questionable content. We're a counterpoint to the narrative here: small (4 full-time people), profitable, and calm. > Even if you just hosted audio Most DMCA takedown requests these days are handled through the big podcast directories (Spotify, Apple Podcasts). We haven't had to write/implement any fingerprinting tech.
- nemo44x 5y ago> We're a counterpoint to the narrative here: small (4 full-time people), profitable, and calm. I hope your model wins in the end but let’s face it - the internet makes available a global market for nearly no marginal cost per user. Networks effects and all that on top of that premise. You can carve out a niche but the serious money will be spent on scale.
- dredmorbius 5y agoCharging also gives a (potential) communications path with the customer, through the payments processor. This can be useful for resolving account issues, which are otherwise a nightmare when there's no identification whatsoever. But any payment also means that you're now fighting against "free" for growth. Free may come either from some massive monopoly who can offer their alternative as a loss-leader, or as a subsidised offering on the back of another monetisation scheme (usually advertising), where revenue potential increases with platform scale. Yes, you'll have fewer issues, but you'll also always be on the short end of the growth stick. This is a rephrasing of another reply to your comment, hopefully with a different and clarifying emphasis.
- SilverRed 5y agoEventually someone will come around and build a "Google docs FUSE" tool that stores arbitrary data in your system. I suspect this is the main reason Google switched docs to actually count against your usage. For normal users you can still store hundreds of millions of documents but it's pointless to encode data in it over just uploading it to drive.