3 ms·
Apple champions fighting climate change yet lobbies against its legislation
- janandonly 5y agoMaybe I am Cynical here... But I guess I know why they do this. You see, as long as there is no law forcing competitors to do what they themselves do, they can claim to be more green/planet concise then all the rest. This chimes well with a certain cohorts of consumers. But if all competitors where forced to be equally “green” this advantage would fall away
- historynops 5y agoI don't think you're being too cynical at all. People need to stop believing the myth that "the market" (aka ordinary customers) will solve the problem by just boycotting companies into submission. I can't think of any instances where this actually happened or the threat actually had any meaningful impact on companies that they didn't internally want to enact already.
- historynops 5y agoAs an addendum, the only powerful force outside of laws for moving a company's position, is its own high-value employees. It's not boycotts, but sometimes its enough employees internally who can get a company to change its ways, but often the execs or some groups will try to band-aid grievances or create illusory changes to try and calm the uproar but still keep doing what they want secretly.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 5y agoEvery corporation does this. It’s just another marketing angle.
- tharne 5y agoBingo. Corporations don't have morals, they have interests. Sometimes those interests can be served by championing this moral cause or that one, but it really doesn't go beyond that.
- simonh 5y agoApple isn't lobbying against the legislation, they are lobbying to change the funding mechanism. Apple has already largely decarbonised their own energy supplies at their own expense. The current legislation is funded by an increase in corporation tax, which they would pay. I can see why they don't want to have to fund everyone else's decarbonisation as well as their own.
- beerandt 5y agoCarbon credits and related offset "products" are going to cost a whole lot more once they become mandated by legislation. Same goes for supply chain costs and retail products downstream of companies subject to those mandates.
- rsj_hn 5y agoThis is why they aren't going to be mandated in the US. There just isn't popular support for costly measures such as this[1], and this complaint (I wouldn't really call it "news") shows the cognitive dissonance that happens when you confuse agreement with a particular cause for commitment to that cause. Neither the US public nor the US government is sufficiently concerned about carbon output to hurt their bottom line, nor is there a willingness to do so. There is, however, great willingness to subsidize various businesses, give out loans, rebates, and other benefits. So knowing that the public has no interest in the stick but always wants carrots, you are better off advocating for research on energy breakthroughs rather than fantasizing about some strict regime of carbon mandates in the US. [1]https://google.com/search?hl=en&q=households%20only%20willing%20to%20spend%20one%20dollar%20per%20day%20on%20climate https://google.com/search?hl=en&q=households%20only%20willin...
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI don't understand what people think they're saying when they use this weird factoid. People don't want to spend much money dealing with climate change? Well, that seems reasonable, so we should use the most effective and efficient methods to deal with it, so we institute a carbon tax and use the full power of modern capitalism to generate solutions cheaply. No wait, it seems we're actually arguing that people do want to spend more money than that on climate change, as long as you don't use it to apply price incentives but instead tax it in some non carbon related manner and hand it out as subsidies? Though in this specific case, Apple is arguing to not fund it through corporate tax rises, which could be seen as a generic tax on everything, which I'd kind of agree with. I want the corporations releasing fossil carbon (equivalents) into the air to pay more, not some random company, because then they have an incentive to stop doing so.