4 ms·
> something I got from reading rules You read some books but you want to argue with someone who literally socialized with a monk? How about this: I was a monk
by cratermoon 5y ago
> something I got from reading rules
You read some books but you want to argue with someone who literally socialized with a monk? How about this: I was a monk. What you're saying is wrong. You do get evenings off at times. Yes, there are some orders that are very strict and isolated, but there are also mendicant and missionary orders.
I know it's tempting to feel we are smart thus we can speak to things of which we have only read, but (and I'm assuming you're in software development because you're here) if a consultant with no actual experience came along and told you how to do your job because "these are best practices", wouldn't you be a bit skeptical?
- davidw 5y agoWould be interesting to hear what countries you all are talking about. I mean, what "Catholic" means in Italy, Ireland, Mexico and the Philippines varies to some degree, for instance.
- antongribok 5y agoIn my case, this was in New York. This was a Christian monastery, but not Catholic.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- whatshisface 5y agoThey say they read some rulebooks that sounded extremely strict, you say there are some monasteries that are extremely strict; you're both agreeing with the language of disagreement.
- cratermoon 5y agoExcept that GP asserted that reading the rulebooks was a substitute for, you know, actually having been there and that people who had were wrong.
- omarfarooq 5y agoI didn’t see where they asserted it was a substitute.
- watwut 5y agoI argued with someone who socialized with people in seminars. Those are not monks. Priests are not monks either. There is also difference between monk and brother, nun and sister. What you are saying is that cloistered somehow don't count. Maybe you was in freest order there is, but the rest of them count too. You also argue absurdly aggressive and arrogant way for a monk. You are not the only ex-monk out there and in fact, ex-monks or those who gave that up during formation do talk about these rules.